I'd choose The Mecca - if only for the fact that I read the argey-bargey about how Levine went off the point (did he?! - progression?!) and am unable to make a biased decision for myself - I have only hearsay and other peoples views to go on
Here's my (at the time, youthful) view of the nighters in my world at my time:
Wigan - believe it all, nowt will ever come near to it's musical urgency (luckily for me I entered it's walls late '79 'til its' gut wrencing end, no footage of how cutting edge it [searling] was).
A truly life changing experience (proper Yorkshire blokes offering me (a kid) water - unforgettable respect if only for he fact you were there - and that was late 70's, early 80s' - not this watered down shit nu- man we have now.)
Brought me up believing Northern wasn't 60's 70's or 80's - Northern was what I heard on that dancefloor then, at that time of my life, and I believe it (the dj's) grounded me, soulfully, for life - I will gratefully cut myself out of the politics of the scene at the time (Keep The Faith Not The Funk etc), if only for the fact I thank God I was around to experience it's 'specialness'. I'll die a happy man.
The last three guitar strums on 'I Don't Like To Lose'....'Mate!?
Rotherham - very little time between Wigan being taken from me and me taking the next step - my first real venture into the world of travelling cross country for my music - a completely different take on the all nighter, musically, but such a fantastic experience. Awful walk from Sheffield in winter though. Brag in the back room with Brian Rae & Martin form Congleton. Yogi shuffling to 'Pusherman', 'Machine' , Charles Johnson and my talc covered moccassins - winning a wank competition LP off ov Dave Evo. Thumbing it home.
Leicester Oddfellows - a bit of a blur generally, good memories of the Anniversary nights.
Hinckley Leisure Centre - Major Lance, Ric Tic Revue, Jr Walker, Curtis Mayfield - cool skinheads with dodgytattoos and baseball court markings that didn't make good for dancing.
100's Club - travelling down with Brian, staying with Cliff White (Charley compiler and his white witch wife) and going to The Old Ball (was it? - Ions early sessions), staying at Kebs or Danny's (rough as) on the Old Caledonian Road - travelling back and knocking out Robert Cray albums on Sunday markets.
Buzzard - an oddity of an evening.
Morecambe Pier - Gibbons whole family chipping in, from nephews serving tea, to his gran taking taking the money on the door - getting snotted on the way over by skinheads generally - loved it though (Alexander O'Neal - 'What's Missing, Luther - 'Let It Slide'), Brian dropping ' Broadway Sissy' at 7 in the morning, being verbally abused by Thommo & Greeney (Pondies for the Pondie boys [blackbeat]) Real 80's Northern gubbins.
Stafford - although it does get some stick from the old boys I still speak to for it's 'real soul' policy (Geaorge Tindley, Clyde McPhatter), it will eternally be Tommy Navarro (it may have been a 100's club play prior, but Stafford for me) and Donald Jenkins, alongside the cracking modern nights (James Cobbin & Prime Cut ). Pete Lawson holds dear at this time for me.
Parr Hall - local venue....being upset at lads coming in off the trains with bloody noses - Warrington Town Lads.
The Carleton, Morecambe - recently played the Modern Room there, don't remember it as the same venue - age probably.
Notts Palais (the Dilly Dally) - revolving dancefloor and all, good memories, again especially of Petes playlists.
King Georges Hall, Blackburn - my memories of this venue aren't really good ones, seems a little skeletal to me now - maybe I was just holding on to my memories. Kev Appleton intimidating me into parting with my Sam Fletcher...never forgave the c***.
Bradford Queens Hall - loved every minute of both rooms, asked to choose I'd go Sam & Arthur downstairs, real progressive soul...and people who cared. Crofty and his (wrong) promtional policies - advertise it soulies as asoul night and ravers as a house night - The Big E-Zee ha ha)
........I am aware right now that I am wankered and may regret this diatribe when I wake up, so I will spare you any more of my sad rattlings about attended venues.
I wouldn't have had my life any other way, I'm happy.
Apologies (note to self, don't come on message boards when you can't ride yer bike home).