No apology required, Mark.
Fascinates me too, particularly as I saw it all develop, evolve and regress before my eyes.
At that point (Clifton Hall days) the scene was truly progressive - playing a mix of old and underplayed, new, newly discovered and recent US product (Soul Music) just as it always had done throughout its history. Fortunately, by then, the just plain 'Bad Northern' and 'Pop Slop' element had been almost completely exorcised from the playlists, with the accent being on continuing progress and soulful quality.
However, by the mid 90's certain sectors decided it would be a good idea to turn the clock back a few decades!
Now I have absolutely no doubt in my mind that the 60's was the finest decade for Soul music, but I felt that there were still good releases coming through in the 70's & 80's that deserved exposure in the ONE room and that these were things which still had appeal for 'Northern' tastebuds.
We did our best to keep it on track (despite the '60's Mafia' backlash) and kept on picking out the newer tunes that still had 'Northern' appeal. For me the real threat was the 'Modern Scene' going off on its own - which, sadly, it eventually did.
But to bring that forward to this century, the sad truth is... the quality just isn't there 'en masse' these days (IMO) and hasn't been for over 10 years - Most of the 'Soulful Dance' around is far more 'dance' than it is TRULY soulful.
I was only saying to Martin Dixon (Cunnie) last night, that I'm quite appalled by much of the tripe that some try to pass off as Soul music these days. For me a lot of this so called 'Soul' that gets played is almost as bad an experience to my ears as listening to Russ and Co at the Casino playing the Gary Lewis and Brian Hylands etc. A far too casual, lazy and easy approach... "Hey... it sounds a bit like Soul... and you can dance like fook to it - so that'll do".
FFS Give me the real vocals... the Johnny Taylor's, the Randy Brown's, Lenny William's, Bobby Womack's, J. Blackfoot's, Carl Simms, Andre Lee's, Shirley Brown's, Anthony Hamilton's please. Most of what I hear these days from the so called 'Soulful' house fraternity just doesn't measure up. In recent times you've got to look REALLY hard to find the true gems and I'm afraid many DJ's (it seems ) just don't have the resources or ears to know the difference between an Omar Cunningham and a Mario Bondi!
Your post has given me an opportunity to speak out on this subject, Mark - (and I'm not counting you in there, cos I know you have history... and an ear) - but I can well see why the 'Northern' crowd don't latch on too readily to some of the tosh which is promoted as 'Soul Music' nowadays.
Fact is - Most of it just aint!
Sean
PS: I quite like Muthafunkaz- but, lets be honest... we're not talkin Darrell Banks here are we.