Some good points raised Andy. Can remember Mark R speaking out against them a few years ago over on EMS & a few people shot him down but are now agreeing with him.
The 2 tracks you chose though (Summat For't Weekend & Tribute) that have crossed over to the Northern scene are probably 2 of the worst records played in Modern rooms recently (IMO) & have both been bastardised into a 7" format anyway so is this not similar to the whole remix/re-edit scenario but kinda in reverse?
Agree r/e the George Benson Gamm remix, totally pointless.
As for the Moulton things the thing we seem to forget is that the originals were limited by the format,i/e 7" vinyl & quite a lot of them had no option but to put part 1 on the a side & part 2 on the b side. Classic example is the guv'nor Harold Melvin - The Love I Lost part 1&2.
Problem for me with a lot of the Moulton Philly remixes is that they are overlong. Probably the best one of the recent crop (IMO) was the Peoples Choice remix of Do It Any Way You Wanna & that only lasts 5-30 as opposed to some of them that are over twice as long.
Also the whole remix thing has been around for years, remember some of the Walter Gibbons things from the mid 70's. Same goes for some of the Morales things & a couple of tracks from the 2013 M&M mixes album were pretty good & the remix of Third World - Now That We Found Love was outstanding again IMO.
Strange thing is nobody seemed to critisize the Dimitri from Paris Philly remixes from a few years ago.
Be interesting to hear Ian Dewhirsts side of this topic.
Quick last question, Ron Hall & the Muthafunkaz - The Way You Love Me - best version?