Alright John,
As a young soulie that's still quite new to it all, my advice would be not to take any notice of the oldies, newies debate and just enjoy listening to and discovering new sounds. I'm hearing tunes that I think are brilliant and are new to me, but others would say they are played out!
Its a no win situation to get involved in these debates because people have very different idea's of what the scene is all about. The soul scene is made of of many different types of soul lover and each type think their outlook is correct and others have no idea.
Dont fall into any catergory and just embrace it for what it means to you.