Not having a knock, Pendulum but I was waiting for someone to say that. Which is most likely?
Track is laid down and Gene & musicians say "Damn that was funky"
Track is laid down and Gene & musicians say "Damn that's a good Northern Soul tune"
The first music venue I ran had a barman who was fanatical about Metal and could only see things in those terms. We had an Irish folk rock band that played regularly (You Slosh for anyone from York / Scarborough area who might remember 'em). They were so good that everyone from punks to folk purists to rock an rollers loved them. Point is Al, the Barman desribed them as "Folk/Metal" ie he liked them so they must be Metal, even though that wasn't remotely the case.
I think this happens on the Northern scene, particularly with oldies from way back. If it's a funky tune that was adopted by the scene, then it stops being funk because it's Northern. What's the problem with accepting that it's funk? You'll all be saying Broadway Sissy is Northern next
Good debate though.
Godz