Couldn't agree more!
Eloise Laws, Willy J and James Fountain were all big plays at Cleethorpes in the 70s, and therefore also Peterborough, St Ives etc (though if you go to an anniversary/revival for the latter two venues now you wouldn't think so)
So how could those of us who embraced them then consider em to be anything other than classic oldies?
Interestingly, having not heard Willy J for yonks, heard Sam play it a while back (immediately after Joseph Webster, went well together IMHO), so next time he was on I asked him to do the same and whether he played it often. He replied that he generally only played it on the Eastern side of the country!
Think a lot of the pidgeon-holing is very subjective and stems from where and when we first heard the type of track which could be called x-over.
(Haven't followed the whole thread so apologies if repeating anything that has already been said )
Careful with the use of the word funk though mate...theres some on the scene will suddenly go off any track which is described by the F word LOL! Same principle as the Wigan diehards who "don't like RnB" but dance their arses off to "That Driving Beat"
I'll shut up now!