I'm not sure if a few stories are getting mixed up here and I think some of this might have originated from Rob Thomas and I.
When we were with George, in the late 90s, I specifically asked him who Mr Lucky was as the name cropped up on Maltese, and other 45s, that he was associated with. He said it was him and he used it as a sort of cover as he had contractual obligations elsewhere and didn't want to cause himself problems. For the same reason he put his wife's name on the writer credit for 'I Have Faith In You' instead of his own.
We then asked if he'd worked anywhere other than the East Coast/Detroit area and he said he'd done some stuff in L.A. including some singing.
You can see where this is going ... so did he know a song called 'Born To Love You' .... yes that was me he responded.... and if you've heard his unreleased Jobete demo of 'Cabin By The Sea' you will note the similarity in vocal styles.
So when we get back to the UK we retell this rather unusual story to a few people to see what they thought of it. I don't think we were that convinced of the connection but wanted to sound people out .. and I think we have to be mindful that at the time nobody had really investigated the true identity of the L.A. Mr Lucky although in retrospect it seems so obvious.... and I think since then it's become a bit of an urban myth.
On reflection I think we didn't interrogate George enough on specifics and as a result chinese whispers have transformed the story from discussion to it being stated as fact
That's all I can tell you
Andy