Hi Simon,
Don't wish to get involved in any semantics or fall outs but maybe it's me that doesn't get it then.
It's phrases like "I live and breath NS" that I struggle to get to grips with in this instance. All die respect but I think what you mean is "I live and breathe the Northern Soul scene". In my world there's a subtle but nonetheless categorical difference. When I commented that some people don't get it, I wasn't referring to NS, the music, or anything other than the fact that this DVD set is treasure trove of performances that have been captured for posterity. Not just for us current fans to enjoy, but for future generations of fans to celebrate also. That's the whole point. There is no film of many of these artists available anywhere apart from this set. The fact that the artists have had to re-record the songs is simply a matter of economics as has been explained on countless ocaisions. The whole of the UK rare Northern Soul set up is based on these artists, the very artists that created what you claim to 'live and breathe'!
If you can't appreciate that that's fair enough, and it's up to you. Therefore, you don't get it. But many of us do.
It reminds me of a banal comment when Brenda Holloway appeared in UK back in the 90s. "It's not the same without a band". He didn't 'get it' either. Yep, I agree it's not the same. But to have Brenda Holloway standing on stage in your home town (Burnley), singing songs that you'd loved for 25 years and more, only a few feet away and then have her spend time with us after, was worth every penny of any admission fee.
I guess some people are just too happy to see their soulful glass half empty, whereas me, I prefer to view it as half full. I'll be getting the DVD set delivered shortly, I'll be pulling a few bottles of wine out the cooler, pushing the furniture back and celebrating the artists performances for what they are, not what I wished they'd been.
As Ian will testify, I'm no fan of much of his production work and have been on the end of some vociferous comments from him, but this set is tour de force of Northern Soul performances and I struggle to see how fans can't see it for what it is.
Back to lurking......