I organise one gig a year. I am not the promoter, there is no promotion, it's simply a gathering of like minded people playing their collections and if folks wanna come join us they are more than welcome and we have a fantastic time together every year. Not all of the people who attend are collectors but it's fair to say that most are. But here's the crux.....I get inundated with people from UK who contact me, explain that they are 'DJ's/Promoters' on the UK Northern Soul scene, most are local 'DJs' who play at their own gigs and their Mates, (some of them actually go on to tell me the history of the UK soul scene ), and offer their services as "DJs". Most play the same records as each other, some play boots.carvers etc and most of us could hear their records without leaving our homes. I explain that the event is a group of long time collectors getting together to share their collections over a weekend, in the sun, with great food, wine, and we dance our asses of for 3 days. Inevitably....VERY FEW of the "DJs" who get in touch, once they realise it's not about names on flyers, or playing the latest Frank Popp gubbins, actually want to join us unless they are 'DJing'. What a farce. But of course......"the only reason they set up their own gigs and DJ at them is they do it for the good of the scene, to hear something different and their passion to share the music with others".
I would venture that in my experience, if a lot of people weren't DJing at their own gigs, they simply wouldn't DJ anywhere else and therefore their interest/involvement with the music would peter out.
I have no axe to grind with 'DJs", some of my close friends are "DJs". It's entirely up to each individual to enjoy the music exactly how they feel it's right for them. How people enjoy their involvement in the soul 'scene' is completely their perogative. But in answer to Des' original question I would answer yes.
I think more and more people are driven by attempting to get that 15 minutes of fame by standing behind a set of Technics and not by a love of the music and a passion to enjoy it with like minded people. That's why our particular weekender "DJs" are by invitation only, all attend as listeners first, DJs second and do so at their own expense. Unique? Maybe not, but it certainly lays a foundation for an enjoyable bootleg/pressing/carver free weekend that usually throws up a few 45s that we start chasing the minute the gig ends.
This years "DJ's" from UK include Dave Greet, Dave Ferguson, Howard Griffin, Alan Pollard, Karl Heard, Russ Vickers, and Chris Dalton. You won't see their names on flyers every weekend at local "dos", or indeed at many national events, but I think it's fair to say that they reflect the ethos of what is best about both the collecting scene and the passion that comes with it when asked to 'DJ'.