Thanks for all those who took the time to comment, both on the forum, and off.
Based on the latest email from Mr Bivins, I'm going to put 'the group who cannot be named' (Oh hang on, I can name them now) The Manhattans discog back on the site:
Mr. Rimmer,
Hello again. Let me first say that I understand your angst over this matter and it is well deserved. Also, let me reassure you that it was never the intent of myself or The Manhattans organization to cause any distress or imply to threaten legal action against you in any way. Although I did not personally authorize the content or the release of that email to you, due to the fact that it was done by someone under my employ as a representative, I must accept responsibility. I deeply apologize and hope that you can continue your proven support for The Manhattans. I want to also let you know that you don't need any type of permission from my attorney to use The Manhattans name on your site, nor will there be any further harrassment or threats to you for continuing to do so. On that you have my complete assurance. We would very much appreciate the re-instatement of The Manhattans on your website and put this unfortunate incident behind us. I also want to truly apologize for not only the content of the original email, but for the tone as well. When I read it for myself, I perceived it as rather confrontative and somewhat arrogant, and not to mention threatening. Please accept our apology for that as well. I have taken steps to guarantee nothing like that will ever happen again.
I invite you to visit our website and read our Group History. I believe you will find a wealth of discographic hitsory which you may find useful. Please feel free to use whatever information you like to incorporate onto your site.
I have also had your site added to our Favorite Links page.
www.themanhattans.net
Again, I sincerely apologize for any problems this has caused and if there is anything you need, please feel free to contact me directly.
Thank You
Sincerely
Edward "Sonny" Bivins
The Manhattans
I think I won that one, don't you