Sorry if any of my following points have been covered already, I am replying to Ian's first post and havent read all the replies.
Firstly, has anyone decided where north ends and south starts? I live in Portsmouth and everything is north from me (fcuk off Isle of Wight) so when I saw Sean Chapman had a do called 'talk of the south' I was a bit miffed!! (Hi Sean)
Any way I have been traveling north (I'm talking north of London) for many months now and there is a difference.
Firstly the dos north are far better attended - obviously due to greater number of people into NS than down south.
Is there different music to be heard north or south? Yes, but as with most nites now the music is as good as the guesting DJ's. Darn sarf there is a venue called Bisley, probably the best attended venue south of the M4 with a regular 300-400 people attending. If I go its cos nothing else is on, its very oldies orientated (not a bad thing please understand, just not my cup of tea) and it is as good as the guest DJ's on.
And no one has to travel that far these days to hear a favorite DJ, why travel miles and hours to hear someone who will be in your area the following week?
As for upfront - it does depend on the venue. I went to the Brighouse Ritz to see Ginger sometime late last year. An oldies orientated venue (and it was brilliant and packed) and Carl W came on and played out and out oldies e.g. wade in the water - Carl obviously done his homework and knew the crowds expectations. Heard Carl a month or so later at Bury and a completely different set. Both up north one oldies one 'upfront' (and a sign of a good DJ IMO).
And to move that on...on the same night as going to Gingers do I went afterwards to the allniter at Wilton. A few miles up the road and another packed(ish) venue! Ok so the music policy between the two is different but that could not happen down south. I used to co-promote a soul nite in Portsmouth, quite 'upfront' compared to the other dos down here - no one in this area and I am talking Brighton to Bournemouth and up to London will clash, to maximize people through the door - and we used to wonder why people wouldn't travel down to our nites. Think it was Russ Vickers who said to me that we could have an all-niter down here with Butch, Fenn, Sam, Smith, Dyson etc DJing and still we wouldn't get the numbers. Well after going up north its quite clear - they don't have to!! There is so much going on up north they don't have to travel down south, no point especially as the good DJ's can be caught almost any where.
For consistency my favorite venue has to be the 100 club and then niter wise Keele - the best venues musically (and I mean I have heard better sets elsewhere, but for the whole nite) I've attended recently have been Scenesville in London and Drunken Monkey in North Wales. All IMO of course and literally miles apart.
I really don't think that I've answered Ian's question at all have I? LOL