Interesting points raised by everybody this morning. If the aim of Russ's thread was to identify A New Top 500, devoid of ties to the 'old order' then what we've had so far is just a list of tracks that may have received their plays after Stafford closed its doors.
There have been undeniably brilliant soul records discovered since 1986. Have there been the amount that could produce a rival to the KR Top 500? I think that's open to debate. A great many of the tracks that have been mentioned wouldn't get in on a qualitative evaluation of either the amount of widespread acceptance they might have received or on how good they might be as records.
Perhaps it's time to start wittling down the list to what I referred to earlier as cast-iron certainties. The three I mentioned above were the Jesse James acetate, Carla Thomas Never Stop and the unissued version of The Prophets on Shrine. Bubbling under that rarified postition would be stuff like The Vanguards on Lamp, The Sensations on Way Out and The San Francisco TKOs.
In terms of nationwide, floorfilling popularity over time, Joseph Webster, Ellipsis and Joe Jama have to be considered on a list of certainly top 50 in the post-Stafford era. Much as we might find it unpalatable we may also have to conclude that Dean Barlow, Lou Lawton, Joey DeLorenzo et al have just as much right to sit in a pantheon of popularity.
Bear in mind as well that the whole Crossover phenomenon as a strand of the Rare Soul scene is post-Stafford, but how many of those tracks (great as many are) have broken out to be classics on the Northern All Nighter scene? Arguably things like James Phelps, Willie Tee "First Taste of Hurt" and a few more, but which have had the presence to be contemporary equivalents of Frank Wilson, Yvonne Baker, Epitome of Sound etc.
I'm not making judgements here, just maybe refining the focus of the thread. I would be interested to hear what everyone has to say. Gambler's Blues, great as it is, may never have the legs to break out of being a cult record: the fate of many current-day spins?