Ted Massey Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 How the hell does he do it Velvettes at £400+ and thats just one example
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 (edited) How the hell does he do it Velvettes at £400+ and thats just one example  link He puts stuff up for sale and then crazy people pay many times the normal price. It is the buyers (whoever they are) who are responsible, people with limited knowledge and lots of money I presume. Edited April 13, 2005 by Guest
Jo Law Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Ans the final price was 686 pounds yes 686 POUNDS --BLOODY MADNESS----JO
Paul McKay Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Ans the final price was 686 pounds yes 686 POUNDS --BLOODY MADNESS----JO link This is even madder Willie Hightower £335
Ted Massey Posted April 13, 2005 Author Posted April 13, 2005 Ans the final price was 686 pounds yes 686 POUNDS --BLOODY MADNESS----JO link how about the Sweet Things on date £155 on Ebay
Dazz Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 How the hell does he do it Velvettes at £400+ and thats just one example link How do you know that he does do it, how do you even know that the records are even there to be auctioned in the first place. What guarentee do you have that if the records are there, he doesn't just bump them up in price to make it look good and increase the price of the real records for sale. It's a good?? marketing ploy to include a load of good records on your auction to entice people to your site, to buy other records. I don't know anyone who has ever bought a record from his auction, do you???? (to be fair I don't know many people though At least on Ebay and other real online auctions you can (usually) safely assume the record is there to be bought and that the highest bidder, that you can see, is the winner Dazz the Unbeliever
Tubbs Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 How do you know that he does do it, how do you even know that the records are even there to be auctioned in the first place. What guarentee do you have that if the records are there, he doesn't just bump them up in price to make it look good and increase the price of the real records for sale. It's a good?? marketing ploy to include a load of good records on your auction to entice people to your site, to buy other records. I don't know anyone who has ever bought a record from his auction, do you???? (to be fair I don't know many people though At least on Ebay and other real online auctions you can (usually) safely assume the record is there to be bought and that the highest bidder, that you can see, is the winner Dazz the Unbeliever link I know somebody who bought a 45 from his auction. I did Bull Bygones on Bell coz i couldn't find one anywhere else. Also sold a 45 through his auction got the money for it so somebody must have bought it.
Gasher Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 This is even madder Willie Hightower £335 link cheap at half the price now who wants to buy my two mint issues for £300 each haha the gasher
pikeys dog Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 I know people who've sold through him... and I've purchased off the auction..... I recently sent him some items, and he must have a rack of things to auction, cos thay ain't gone up yet.... If he was auctioning phantom records, then surely mine would have been up for sale earlier... after all 10% of my final price is better than bogger all.... WOOF!
Guest Johnny One Trout Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 cheap at half the price now who wants to buy my two mint issues for £300 each haha the gasher link I blame you entirely for this one you've been banging on about it for so long now people must think it's not a ten pound record anymore great though it is someone was seen coming a mile off
Simon T Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Ans the final price was 686 pounds yes 686 POUNDS --BLOODY MADNESS----JO link Once again a £100 record goes for silly mone.y I've said this before, if this is a valid auction result, there must be one person putting in a bid a few quid behind, because it's an auction that claims to use proxy bidding, like ebay. As we can't 'access' this person like ebay, you can't offer a similar record for their second place bid and see if they are for real. However, anyone can sign up to the auction and bid against the true bidder i.e. the same person with a thousand pseudonyms who could always be the second highest 'bidder' . The other strange thing is that, like the Silouettes this week (~£1100), the winning bid always seems to be about 4X the 'set sale' value of the record. If the second place bidder is reading this, you can have my rarer black issue (vg+) for £670!
MarkWhiteley Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Anyone catch what the Videls made? Meant to bid but forgot all about it.
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 How do you know that he does do it, how do you even know that the records are even there to be auctioned in the first place. What guarentee do you have that if the records are there, he doesn't just bump them up in price to make it look good and increase the price of the real records for sale. It's a good?? marketing ploy to include a load of good records on your auction to entice people to your site, to buy other records. I don't know anyone who has ever bought a record from his auction, do you???? (to be fair I don't know many people though At least on Ebay and other real online auctions you can (usually) safely assume the record is there to be bought and that the highest bidder, that you can see, is the winner Dazz the Unbeliever link Dazz, I know people who have placed records with him for auction (infact just sent him one my self) and they have received their money from him. John Manship gets a lot of stick on the scene but i've had no problems with him in 20 years either buying or selling. Blame the people who pay the huge amounts. E-bay's far from perfect with some sellers getting their mates to bid for their items to push the prices up. Derek
Wiganer1 Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Dazz, I know people who have placed records with him for auction (infact just sent him one my self) and they have received their money from him. John Manship gets a lot of stick on the scene but i've had no problems with him in 20 years either buying or selling. Blame the people who pay the huge amounts. E-bay's far from perfect with some sellers getting their mates to bid for their items to push the prices up. Derek link =============== here here ive been buying from john since i was 16... top man in my book always talks to you,,asks how u are and what im collecting at the mo
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 The auctions are definitely real, and there are definitely at least two people bidding against each other. The scary thing IMO is that someone actually pays these prices. It has long been something of a joke but it seems that now (at least to some people) "£1000 is the new £100". Things like Willie Hightower for £300+ is truly a joke (not to mention Brown Sugar for £600, ouch...). There was a mint copy of Willie Hightower on ebay that I bid on (to sell on) but I lost, the end price was £20, and it was exactly one week ago! How can a £15 record on a major label go from £15 to £300+ in a few months time? £15 to £50 yeah maybe if people are desperate, but £15 to £300+?! Who are these people? Someone MUST know them, or even be them!
Simon T Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Who are these people? Someone MUST know them, or even be them! link
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 I can guarantee you that 99% of the people responsible for all the craziest prices ARE indeed UK residents. Watch ebay and the morons paying thousands for Bill Bush etc. and they are always in the UK with very few exceptions.
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 I think that so called returnees are the main offenders.
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 =============== here here ive been buying from john since i was 16... top man in my book always talks to you,,asks how u are and what im collecting at the mo link Second that!!and he allways give you decent prices when buying,dont have go through loads of fucking about,though not sold anything to him for ages now.
Simon T Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 I can guarantee you that 99% of the people responsible for all the craziest prices ARE indeed UK residents. Watch ebay and the morons paying thousands for Bill Bush etc. and they are always in the UK with very few exceptions. link er, 99% of people into this 'Northern' bollocks, in whatever way, are probably UK residents, like fish n' chips, football hooligans, xenophobia, we invented it!
Guest Posted April 13, 2005 Posted April 13, 2005 Who are these people? Someone MUST know them, or even be them! link Modern day Howard Hughes into Northern? Obviously not UK residents as they could get out and look through a few record boxes and see the current going rates. Never recieved a list from one of the major dealers in the last twenty years. Have WWW access, but no email accounts as they don't get any current list emailed to them. Have been to every do from Va Va's to Plinstone, to have bought into every 'in demand, world-wide floor filling, missing from top collector's boxes, next monster, current sleeper' sound............... link
Sunnysoul Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 The reality is that there are loads of genuine and serious soul collectors who , for very good reasons such as work or family , have a reasonably large income but neither the time nor inclination to go trawling through ebay lists or websites or spending hours going to record shops or record fairs or sorting through 1000's of records in warehouses BUT regard Mr Manships site as a very simple easy safe accessible and convenient way to buy rare soul records..............
Simon T Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 The reality is that there are loads of genuine and serious soul collectors who , for very good reasons such as work or family , have a reasonably large income but neither the time nor inclination to go trawling through ebay lists or websites or spending hours going to record shops or record fairs or sorting through 1000's of records in warehouses BUT regard Mr Manships site as a very simple easy safe accessible and convenient way to buy rare soul records.............. link ovenchip i love you
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 =============== here here ive been buying from john since i was 16... top man in my book always talks to you,,asks how u are and what im collecting at the mo link John`s never done much wrong in my book either. His records may seem more expensive but his service has always been quick and reliable. And the grading of his stuff is accurate.If he states anything`s mint-you can be sure it is. And I don`t mind paying a little extra if everything`s right...But he has done a few things wrong in my book..like selling that cottonpickin` price guide to the Americans..and ruining it for us over here...Would we have all these attempted scams by Americans on eBay for records that don`t exist otherwise? No of course not..We`d still be buying records from the States (like my avatar) for next to nothing instead of for thousands.....Our buddies from the States are ready for us now......
Steve G Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 =============== ive been buying from john since i was 16... top man in my book always talks to you,,asks how u are and what im collecting at the mo link Likewise - have been buying from John since the late 70s - never had any problem with him.
Guest the dukester Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 (edited) Ans the final price was 686 pounds yes 686 POUNDS --BLOODY MADNESS----JO link SIMPLE, ITS DOWN TO 2 PEOPLE WHO WANT THAT PARTICULAR RECORD ISNT IT? I FOR ONE THINK THE WAY HE RUNS THE AUCTION IS VERY FAIR, BID IN THE LAST 5 MINUTES AND IT EXTENDS THE AUCTION BY 5 MINUTES, GIVING YOU TIME TO THINK ABOUT BIDDING AGAIN, COME ON, THE MANS GOT A GOOD HEAD FOR BUSINESS HASNT HE? ITS YOUR MONEY, YOU SPEND IT HOW YOU WANT, NO ONE IS PUTTING A GUN TO YOUR HEAD. I HAVE BOUGHT RECORDS FROM HIS AUCTION AND HAD RECORDS ON HIS AUCTION, MONEY HAS ALWAYS BEEN PAID STRAIGHT AWAY. PEOPLE ALWAYS GO ON ABOUT HIS PRICE GUIDE, DONT FORGET, ITS ONLY A GUIDE, NOT CAST IN STONE, A RECORD IS ONLY WORTH AS MUCH AS YOU ARE WILLING TO PAY. ISNT THERE MORE DISHONEST PEOPLE OUT THERE IN E BAY LAND ??? WHY DO MOST PEOPLE QUOTE "MANSHIPS SITE" WHEN SELLING A RECORD??? THE GUY KNOWS HIS STUFF Edited April 14, 2005 by the dukester
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 The reality is that there are loads of genuine and serious soul collectors who , for very good reasons such as work or family , have a reasonably large income but neither the time nor inclination to go trawling through ebay lists or websites or spending hours going to record shops or record fairs or sorting through 1000's of records in warehouses BUT regard Mr Manships site as a very simple easy safe accessible and convenient way to buy rare soul records.............. link I agree in a way and I have personally always been treated well by John and had some good records off him, and quite cheap too sometimes! Someone who pays £335 for Willie Hightower is NOT a genuine and serious collector though, such a person is a moron, or more like a raving madman. Genuine and serious collectors usually have a good idea of things rarity and so on, if not they are not genuine and serious collectors, simple as that. Genuine and serious collectors do NOT pay hundreds and hundreds for common records on major labels that have always been £15 up until a fortnight ago. Genuine and serious collectors, give us a break.
Wally Francis Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 I blame these want a be djs,some re-mortgageing there houses getting thousands of pounds and just going mental and buying anything and everything.And Manship will gladly take there cash of them and in a couple of years time buy them back at a quarter of the price very good business management in my book. I myself think it's a lazy way of collecting i like the chase trying to find that little piece of black plastic for only a few $$$ then sending it to Manship and watch the mug's buying it or taking to night's were they are djing and happily taking the green of them. LOVE IT
Paul McKay Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 Anybody know what Chico Lamarr went for ? link £1485
Rich Buckley Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 such a person is a moron, or more like a raving madman. Don't pull your punches Christian I do like the cut of your dismissive gib!!! There is a certain beauty in the way that some non UK english speaking people phrase things - sometimes it is brutal and may be lost in translation, but it bloody tickles me!!!
Rich Buckley Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 No morons bidding on that then link That's right Steve, must have been a raving madman
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 That's right Steve, must have been a raving madman link
Gasher Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 No morons bidding on that then link I know a man who just paid 3K for it??? the gasher
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 (edited) I know a man who just paid 3K for it??? the gasher link I thought it would fetch £2500. I had bid on it but got stuck in a meeting at work and missed the end. Would have paid more than £1485, but of course you don't know what the eventual winner would have gone too. A bargain methinks ! Edited April 14, 2005 by BLADEFORLIFE
chrissie Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 I think that so called returnees are the main offenders. link Not this returnee - never paid more the 15 squid QOF X
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 Don't pull your punches Christian I do like the cut of your dismissive gib!!! There is a certain beauty in the way that some non UK english speaking people phrase things - sometimes it is brutal and may be lost in translation, but it bloody tickles me!!! link Well it's the truth is it not? The truth is often brutal. There is no justification of any kind for paying £335 for a relatively common record on a major label that was recently (like a week ago) a £15 - £20 record is there? If you are the Sultan of Brunei or something and got into this northern thing a couple of weeks ago and on a whim decide at breakfast that "I gotta have that Willie Hightower" and then pay £335 later that day, OK, I can understand that since nothing you do will drastically decrease your fortune anyway, but there are not too many sultans into northern are there? It is the sheep herd mentality that strikes again. "Oh what's this hot new sound, gotta have that and play out, never mind what it costs, bah, bahhh..". Same thing with Gayle Adams etc. Still it's not all bad this craze, the good thing is that there is easy money to be made on todays fluctuations, money that can be spent on good records.
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 Still it's not all bad this craze, the good thing is that there is easy money to be made on todays fluctuations, money that can be spent on good records. link Thought you only bought good records anyway Christian ? Steve
Guest Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 Thought you only bought good records anyway Christian ? Steve link I buy bad records occasionally, I buy all sorts really, but for myself I only keep things that I consider good. Willie Hightower is a pretty decent record, but so is JJ Barnes "Please Let Me In" but that is still no reason paying £250 for it, which would be just as crazy.
Guest Awake 502 Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 How do you know that he does do it, how do you even know that the records are even there to be auctioned in the first place. What guarentee do you have that if the records are there, he doesn't just bump them up in price to make it look good and increase the price of the real records for sale. It's a good?? marketing ploy to include a load of good records on your auction to entice people to your site, to buy other records. I don't know anyone who has ever bought a record from his auction, do you???? (to be fair I don't know many people though At least on Ebay and other real online auctions you can (usually) safely assume the record is there to be bought and that the highest bidder, that you can see, is the winner Dazz the Unbeliever link He has sold a few things for me at auction and I have always been 100% satisfied with the service he has given me. Why should I risk putting things on Ebay when they generally sell for less money ?
Iancsloft Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 I think that so called returnees are the main offenders. link =============================================== ABDUCTEES more likely them little grey men dont half fu-k up your head
Guest Rich Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 How do you know that he does do it, how do you even know that the records are even there to be auctioned in the first place. What guarentee do you have that if the records are there, he doesn't just bump them up in price to make it look good and increase the price of the real records for sale. It's a good?? marketing ploy to include a load of good records on your auction to entice people to your site, to buy other records. I don't know anyone who has ever bought a record from his auction, do you???? (to be fair I don't know many people though At least on Ebay and other real online auctions you can (usually) safely assume the record is there to be bought and that the highest bidder, that you can see, is the winner Dazz the Unbeliever link er, I don't think he has to bump the prices up mate when people are chucking money at him - and I especially love it when they're throwing money when he's selling them for me. In fact, I'd hazard a guess that a high percentage that he auctions are not his own records. He probably makes enough cash elsewhere - the last time I was there checking through the thousands of obscurities he's got some bloke asked him how much discount he'd give him if he spent 15 grand - and would the discount go up incrementally if he spent 20, 25 or 30 Seems strange that folk will spend their inheritance in 6 months on vinyl then moan when they have to send their kids to Uni
Mak Posted April 14, 2005 Posted April 14, 2005 Dealt with him once , did'nt get the record it ordered got a credit note instead, that said he runs a bussiness. So if you don't like his prices do what I do DON'T LOOK
Sweeney Posted April 15, 2005 Posted April 15, 2005 (edited) It seems every Manship auction end we get this type of post. Perhaps it's time to move on. Yes, I agree that the closing bids are ludicrous, but that's the Rare Soul scene for you. People like to spend more money on records than they're worth - it's what the scene has mostly been about, really. Why buy a record cheaply when you can pay through the nose for it and impress your mates! Are these auction records REALLY worth what people are paying for them? No. Are they even worth what the average Rare Soul fan is willing to pay for them? Probably not. Everyone seems to be happy enough about these auctions - from the idiots paying top dollar for records that are (relatively) easy to get elsewhere to Manship and the people who send the stuff in for him to auction. Even down to Soul Sourcers moaning about them! Fair play to Mr Manship: he's always been very reasonable with regard to trades etc. If there's ever been a record that I've really wanted, he either has it, or knows where one can be had. Bear in mind that as a business he has to pay wages, VAT, etc. so can't really compete on price with the 50 count box man selling some spares at a do. Do what I do - don't bid and find them elsewhere for a lot less. Edited April 15, 2005 by sweeney
Guest Johnny One Trout Posted April 15, 2005 Posted April 15, 2005 Obviously there are the many aberations on John's auctions but people quickly forget that there are plenty of records that sell for the current market value and in some cases less on the same auctions. Surely it's a case of you pays your money and you makes your choice when it comes to the Manship Lotto not all are destined to sky rocket
Dave Moore Posted April 16, 2005 Posted April 16, 2005 Always had good service from John for over 20 years, and in fact if you dig around in his catalogue there are still some nice bits to be found. Buy for tomorrow NOT yesterday is my motto. Too much competition for the medium rare oldies nowadays from the returnee wannabee DJ crowd. As far as some of the astronomical prices are concerned. All sorts bid on his auctions. Loads on here have admitted it to it in one breath and then "complain" about someone else doing it a week later! . And if you want to sell something, loads of people go scuttering off to John's hoping to make a killing. You can't have it both ways can you? VelVets on 20th Century Fox at 450 quid! Scary stuff indeed! But rekkid collections are like the stock market, they are only worth what you sell them for. If you don't sell then they become valueless in monetary terms. Therefore my 30 year collection is worth absoulutely NOTHING. And that's just the way I like it!! Regards, Dave www.hitsvillesoulclub.com
Guest Posted April 16, 2005 Posted April 16, 2005 Always had good service from John for over 20 years, and in fact if you dig around in his catalogue there are still some nice bits to be found. Buy for tomorrow NOT yesterday is my motto. Too much competition for the medium rare oldies nowadays from the returnee wannabee DJ crowd. As far as some of the astronomical prices are concerned. All sorts bid on his auctions. Loads on here have admitted it to it in one breath and then "complain" about someone else doing it a week later! . And if you want to sell something, loads of people go scuttering off to John's hoping to make a killing. You can't have it both ways can you? Dave www.hitsvillesoulclub.com link Well, I've just rejoined the list after a lengthy abscence...don't get 'round to posting much, as all my free time is spent tracking / looking for records. I've met John at several big USA record shows, he has even bought from me (and always inquires for a discount on his pile . Haven't seen him tho in quite some time. He always says if I want to 'blow out' my rare northerns he would get me top price, better than eBay. Just had to pay taxes on my eBay auctions for the past year, 2200 USD, but that was due to the nutty prices paid by your fellow UK wax hoarders - $661 for Little Joe Cook on original Two-Jay $500+ for Harry Starr on End, and a few others, not-so-rare but achieved astonishing prices. All I can say is that I love Ebay! Wonder what my M- /EX+ copy of Al Williams on Palmer would bring nowadays? The mind boggles. Wish I could buy more stuff from my fave dealers in the UK but our dollar is weaker than a beat up copy of Danny Moore.... USA Mike
Guest Posted April 17, 2005 Posted April 17, 2005 (edited) I myself have gotten some fair trades with John. I was actually surprised at the prices I got. He's the soul scenes whipping boy, or so it seems. Have to give him credit for not resorting to petty retaliation, though. Like some other big names on the scene have done. Edited April 17, 2005 by recordwanted
Guest Andy BB Posted April 18, 2005 Posted April 18, 2005 Do what I do - don't bid and find them elsewhere for a lot less. link Great idea. Can you find me a Chapter 5 please? He's got one on there at the moment. Nail on the head. He does get hard to find records, if you have the cash why wait a year or more until another one comes up? And you know that if it says mint it's going to be just that.
Recommended Posts
Get involved with Soul Source
Add your comments now
Join Soul Source
A free & easy soul music affair!
Join Soul Source now!Log in to Soul Source
Jump right back in!
Log in now!