Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 following on from the elvis conversation .... you hear a tune and you like it , but then you find out the artist doesn't exactly have credibility on the soul scene ...do you baulk at playing it or do you go by your ears . it's obvious that i would play it (previous set lists have shown a certain ...erm unpredictability in that sense lol ) and it is also obvious that some people would allow pre-conceptions ( resisting the word snobbery) to cloud their judgement on a tune ... so the question is where to you stand ?? Davie
Guest Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 following on from the elvis conversation .... you hear a tune and you like it , but then you find out the artist doesn't exactly have credibility on the soul scene ...do you baulk at playing it or do you go by your ears . it's obvious that i would play it (previous set lists have shown a certain ...erm unpredictability in that sense lol ) and it is also obvious that some people would allow pre-conceptions ( resisting the word snobbery) to cloud their judgement on a tune ... so the question is where to you stand ?? Davie link Well Davie i've only ever judged music with my ears, so if it sounds up to the task, then the baby would be in my box.
Soulsmith Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Tricky one that. Attaching a sound file below. Record is a dancers delight, but may be offensive to soul fans! Not sure if it got played out much.
Guest alison Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Any artist with name with a prefix, ie Screaming, Fat, Howling, Blind, Big, Little (there are exception to the "little" rule) etc.....just sounds too Swampy for my tastes. I think I'd also give Girls Aloud a miss
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Any artist with name with a prefix, ie Screaming, Fat, Howling, Blind, Big, Little (there are exception to the "little" rule) etc.....just sounds too Swampy for my tastes. I think I'd also give Girls Aloud a miss link hmmm i'm likely to play anyone WITH a prefix lolol and ali i think you know by now if girls aloud done a tune i could get away with i'd bloody play it hahahahaha Davie ps only kidding
davidwapples Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 isnt there a track on ebay by dolly parton that keeps gettrng mentioned as a northern soul track , whats that all about listed around 50 75 quid !!!!!!
Petebangor Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 A Lulu track gets played in the modern rooms,what a great dancer it is too!
Guest Richard Bergman Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Well Davie i've only ever judged music with my ears, so if it sounds up to the task, then the baby would be in my box. link I agree with your sentiments there Brett , If the track is good enough the credibility of the artist shoul'nt matter - Credibility is a hard thing to define , particularly on a scene such as ours were certain artists have vast cannons of work
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 following on from the elvis conversation .... you hear a tune and you like it , but then you find out the artist doesn't exactly have credibility on the soul scene ...do you baulk at playing it or do you go by your ears . it's obvious that i would play it (previous set lists have shown a certain ...erm unpredictability in that sense lol ) and it is also obvious that some people would allow pre-conceptions ( resisting the word snobbery) to cloud their judgement on a tune ... so the question is where to you stand ?? Davie link With the Elvis track I would go by my ears, and not play it. I actually love Elvis, the only other artist I listen to outside of soul so not just saying this cause it's an Elvis track. Must be desperate to be different if you have to resort to Elvis as well IMHO. There is so much unknown/forgotten, lesser/semi known soul/northern soul out there that can be played to make you different from other DJ's, not just expensive but 100's of cheap 45's.
Guest Richard Bergman Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 A Lulu track gets played in the modern rooms,what a great dancer it is too! link Honestly , I 'd love to hear it , Any chance of a soundfile ?
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 talking about Lulu......leave a little love is fantastic! better than the already brilliant patti austin in my opinion. shane
pikeys dog Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 A Lulu track gets played in the modern rooms,what a great dancer it is too! link Her version of 'Leave A Little Love' is pretty tasty as well.....
Guest Richard Bergman Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 SNAP! link Her version of leave a little love is pretty tasty aswell
Guest Richard Bergman Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 isnt there a track on ebay by dolly parton that keeps gettrng mentioned as a northern soul track , whats that all about listed around 50 75 quid !!!!!! link Yeah Carl W plays it ! - Not very good , prefer Jolene any day
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 With the Elvis track I would go by my ears, and not play it. I actually love Elvis, the only other artist I listen to outside of soul so not just saying this cause it's an Elvis track. Must be desperate to be different if you have to resort to Elvis as well IMHO. There is so much unknown/forgotten, lesser/semi known soul/northern soul out there that can be played to make you different from other DJ's, not just expensive but 100's of cheap 45's. link "desperate to be different " not at all ...i'd love to play the same style of tunes everyone does but i'm afraid i can only be true to myself and no one else ....now maybe that makes what i play different ..not ashamed of that and i ain't gonna apologise for not fitting in with your ideas... as for resorting to playing elvis i had another 70-odd tracks wih me apart from the 25-26 i played so i didn't RESORT to playing anything .. my only concern is ..did people dance and enjoy it? ...YES... did they come up and ask about it ? ....YES ... and as i was DJ'ing for THEM and not YOU your opinion don't count for much on this particular matter ..commenting on the track is one thing but referring to me as being "desperate " is a little insulting Davie
Guest Richard Bergman Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 "desperate to be different " not at all ...i'd love to play the same style of tunes everyone does but i'm afraid i can only be true to myself and no one else ....now maybe that makes what i play different ..not ashamed of that and i ain't gonna apologise for not fitting in with your ideas... as for resorting to playing elvis i had another 70-odd tracks wih me apart from the 25-26 i played so i didn't RESORT to playing anything .. my only concern is ..did people dance and enjoy it? ...YES... did they come up and ask about it ? ....YES ... and as i was DJ'ing for THEM and not YOU your opinion don't count for much on this particular matter ..commenting on the track is one thing but referring to me as being "desperate " is a little insulting Davie link Its all about opinion and bottle - Trying something different should never be scorned at but applauded
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 (edited) "desperate to be different " not at all ...i'd love to play the same style of tunes everyone does but i'm afraid i can only be true to myself and no one else ....now maybe that makes what i play different ..not ashamed of that and i ain't gonna apologise for not fitting in with your ideas... as for resorting to playing elvis i had another 70-odd tracks wih me apart from the 25-26 i played so i didn't RESORT to playing anything .. my only concern is ..did people dance and enjoy it? ...YES... did they come up and ask about it ? ....YES ... and as i was DJ'ing for THEM and not YOU your opinion don't count for much on this particular matter ..commenting on the track is one thing but referring to me as being "desperate " is a little insulting Davie link If my opinion doesn't count then why ask what I wouldn't play or anyone else for that matter who wishes to comment? As this topic relates directly to the Elvis track you played you are going to get a comment or two If you don't want my opinion don't ask if I have one you will get it whether you like it or not Edited February 21, 2005 by chalky
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 If my opinion doesn't count then why ask what I wouldn't play or anyone else for that matter who wishes to comment? If you don't want my opinion don't ask if I have one you will get it whether you like it or not link i wasn't saying your opinion on the track doesn't matter ...you've given that on every forum i'm on i think , i said that in my mind the opinion of the punters i played it for counts for more ... i said at the end commenting on the track is fair enough , and i'm big enough to take criticism on anything i play HOWEVER accusing me of being desperate to be different wasn't nice and i don't think i deserved it Davie
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 The desperate comment wasn't aimed at you directly, it's aimed at anyone who has to resort to Elvis, Dolly f***** Parton or bloody Lulu.
pikeys dog Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 The desperate comment wasn't aimed at you directly, it's aimed at anyone who has to resort to Elvis, Dolly f***** Parton or bloody Lulu. link What about Dusty Springfield? Prefer her version of 'What's It Gonna Be' and she did a pretty good version of 'Bring Him Back'
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 The desperate comment wasn't aimed at you directly, it's aimed at anyone who has to resort to Elvis, Dolly f***** Parton or bloody Lulu. link fair enough ...i'll accept that .... i don't see it as anything but playing a tune i liked. i would imagine the same way you listen to tunes ..the difference is i don't care who sings them if they fit what i want Davie
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 What about Dusty Springfield? Prefer her version of 'What's It Gonna Be' and she did a pretty good version of 'Bring Him Back' link What about her
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 What about Dusty Springfield? Prefer her version of 'What's It Gonna Be' and she did a pretty good version of 'Bring Him Back' link and" haunted" and "don't forget about me" are brilliant .....played both them out as well Davie
Guest Rich Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 ..............................bloody Lulu. link why does anyone play Lulu's 'Leave a little love' when you can resort to the queen herself, Patti Austin :good: personally, I can't understand why George Burley insists on keep playing that Marco Reich thing. Idle german effer :diablo:
pikeys dog Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 What about her link Go on....... Or what about the Welsh Sex God....... Tom Jones. His version of 'I Just Can't Break The News' pisses all over Ben E Kings from a great height. Discuss. WOOF!
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 (edited) Go on....... Or what about the Welsh Sex God....... Tom Jones. His version of 'I Just Can't Break The News' pisses all over Ben E Kings from a great height. Discuss. WOOF! link It would be boring if we liked the same stuff...for a start we'd have sod all to argue about Edited February 21, 2005 by chalky
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 why does anyone play Lulu's 'Leave a little love' when you can resort to the queen herself, Patti Austin :good: personally, I can't understand why George Burley insists on keep playing that Marco Reich thing. Idle german effer :diablo: link cos lulu's version is ace! patti austins version is ace too but lulu has the edge. come on mate there isnt much in it. its a fantastic attempt by the annoying little ginger scot! shane
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Go on....... Or what about the Welsh Sex God....... Tom Jones. His version of 'I Just Can't Break The News' pisses all over Ben E Kings from a great height. Discuss. WOOF! link i'm warming to you ...if i had of remembered it i would have played that on saturday as well but i forgot it ...SUPERB tune Davie
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 cos lulu's version is ace! patti austins version is ace too but lulu has the edge. come on mate there isnt much in it. its a fantastic attempt by the annoying little ginger scot! shane link Annoying little ginger scot, couldn't have put that better myself However has the edge over Patti, are you still suffering from the excess of Saturday night
Guest dundeedavie Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 cos lulu's version is ace! patti austins version is ace too but lulu has the edge. come on mate there isnt much in it. its a fantastic attempt by the annoying little ginger scot! shane link Oi my kids are annoying little ginger scots lolol Davie
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Annoying little ginger scot, couldn't have put that better myself However has the edge over Patti, are you still suffering from the excess of Saturday night link chalky mate I wasnt there at lifeline on saturday. wish i was but i had a birthday bash for a friend in sheffield. will be at the next one for sure. seeing as you are mr hard-drive! why dont you post up patti and lulu for the public to decide. i love them both but my money is on that bird who likes to SHOUT! Shane
Guest rachel Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 I wouldn't NOT play something just because of who the artist was (played the odd Dusty track sometimes, 'Here She Comes' I think is great). But I do think there can be the temptation to play a track JUST because it's a different version or for 'surprise value' rather than on its own merits and with particularly distinctive voices I'm not sure they always blend well with the more 'conventional' (for want of a better word) soul tracks.
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Oi my kids are annoying little ginger scots lolol Davie link i have a sister with the same problem mate. i made her life hell growing up.
Guest rachel Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 (edited) Go on....... Or what about the Welsh Sex God....... Tom Jones. His version of 'I Just Can't Break The News' pisses all over Ben E Kings from a great height. Discuss. WOOF! link Disagree, it's not bad but it sounds like he is trying to sound like Ben E King! Oh and the backing is a bit lounge-singer-ish Edited February 21, 2005 by rachel
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 chalky mate I wasnt there at lifeline on saturday. wish i was but i had a birthday bash for a friend in sheffield. will be at the next one for sure. seeing as you are mr hard-drive! why dont you post up patti and lulu for the public to decide. i love them both but my money is on that bird who likes to SHOUT! Shane link I know you wasn't there, you was drunk in Sheffield so I was told I asked if you are still sufferiing cause I think it may have clouded your judgement regarding Lulu or Patti Haven' t got Lulu version on PC but here's Patti's effort which pisses all over Lulu IMHO
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 I know you wasn't there, you was drunk in Sheffield so I was told I asked if you are still sufferiing cause I think it may have clouded your judgement regarding Lulu or Patti Haven' t got Lulu version on PC but here's Patti's effort which pisses all over Lulu IMHO link i forgot you only had 'quality soul' prestatyn chalky? i think we should do another roll call. i like those.
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 come on who has a soundfile of lulu? its marginally better chalky i am afraid. shane
Chalky Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 i forgot you only had 'quality soul' prestatyn chalky? i think we should do another roll call. i like those. link Not true Shane, there's plenty of shit soul on the hard drive too About time it had a clean up though I'll be at Prestatyn
pikeys dog Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Disagree, it's not bad but it sounds like he is trying to sound like Ben E King! Oh and the backing is a bit lounge-singer-ish link Ben E Kings vocal is as weak as old womens tea. Good Old Tom belts it out with conviction. Must have Scotch pies stuck in yer ears! WOOF!
Guest rachel Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Ben E Kings vocal is as weak as old womens tea. Good Old Tom belts it out with conviction. Must have Scotch pies stuck in yer ears! WOOF! link Wondered where the bits of pastry were coming from.... TOM BEN
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 Wondered where the bits of pastry were coming from.... TOM BEN link both great! tom has the edge for me. shane
Guest rachel Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 rachel, you not got lulu have ya? link No fraid not (well actually dunno if fraid or not as I've never heard it!)
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 No fraid not (well actually dunno if fraid or not as I've never heard it!) link its great rachel. take my word for it. dont listen to chalky. he is wrong on this one.
Paul R Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 If presley has a place in the "modern" soul scene then I don't think I'll bother. I have heard all the crap abouth the sounds played now are more soulful than in the Wigan era. I think there is such a lot of selective "right on soulfulness" that it can make a mockerey of enjoyment of a scene that consists of a love of predominantly soulful dance sounds. Paul
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 If presley has a place in the "modern" soul scene then I don't think I'll bother. I have heard all the crap abouth the sounds played now are more soulful than in the Wigan era. I think there is such a lot of selective "right on soulfulness" that it can make a mockerey of enjoyment of a scene that consists of a love of predominantly soulful dance sounds. Paul link have you heard the said tune Paul? i haven't but i could never pass judgement on something until i have heard it. apart from maybe Michael Barrymore or something as stupid as that. shane
hipshaker 05 Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 nothing's out of bounds for us ....... if it can stand up as a decent dancefloor track .... tom jones ... elvis ... peggy lee ...... sandie shaw ..... lulu ..... cliff ..... cilla ..... some good tracks from that motley crew.
Guest ShaneH Posted February 21, 2005 Posted February 21, 2005 nothing's out of bounds for us ....... if it can stand up as a decent dancefloor track .... tom jones ... elvis ... peggy lee ...... sandie shaw ..... lulu ..... cliff ..... cilla ..... some good tracks from that motley crew. link cliff? at least you get better weather on the south coast shane
Chalky Posted February 22, 2005 Posted February 22, 2005 (edited) If presley has a place in the "modern" soul scene then I don't think I'll bother. I have heard all the crap abouth the sounds played now are more soulful than in the Wigan era. I think there is such a lot of selective "right on soulfulness" that it can make a mockerey of enjoyment of a scene that consists of a love of predominantly soulful dance sounds. Paul link have you heard the said tune Paul? i haven't but i could never pass judgement on something until i have heard it. apart from maybe Michael Barrymore or something as stupid as that. shane link Posted the soundfile in sounds under whatya reckon Edited February 22, 2005 by chalky
Recommended Posts
Get involved with Soul Source
Add your comments now
Join Soul Source
A free & easy soul music affair!
Join Soul Source now!Log in to Soul Source
Jump right back in!
Log in now!