Another Take ?

[SteveM]

SoulClub has an "unedited" version of " Band Of Gold". Better than the brilliant original. Any info anyone ?

[Guest TONY ROUNCE]

SoulClub has an "unedited" version of " Band Of Gold". Better than the brilliant original. Any info anyone ?

I don't agree with you at all that it's "better than the brilliant original" - for a start, it IS the original, which the best known and chart topping version was edited down and remixed from - but the story is that, having cut it in the long format, H-D-H realised that it was a bit meandering, and that it lacked punch for radio play, so they cut out the unnnecessary 'bridge' and - from memory - a verse, replaced the weak intro with something a bit more punchy from elsewhere in the record, added some memorable backing vocals and generally made a good, 4 minute 'work in progress' record into a 2 1/2 minute amazing one.

Although it would have charted, I believe that it would never have become the hit that it was had it not undergone this major 'reconstructive surgery'.

It's been issued several times - indeed, I put it on a V/A Invictus compilation when I was running Sequel in the late 90s - but credit for unearthing it and, indeed, for issuing it first goes to Neil Rushton who put it out on the flip of a a gold vinyl Inferno reissue of the hit version of BOG, c. 1980....

[Billy Freemantle]

Agree that the issued number 1 hit is by far the best. But the longer version (ie the one Chalky put up) is still very sweet.It does lack the drama of the short version though. I can still remember the thrill that the intro to that record gave me when it was played in a club or when it came on the radio.

Edited June 1, 2007 by Billy Freemantle

[Guest dundeedavie]

does it not change the entire "story " so to speak , with the released version implying the wife being spurned by the husband whereas the original implies the opposite

[Guest Netspeaky]

Anybody interested in the INFERNO version, I have one for sale, pm me.

[Sunnysoul]

There is a surprisingly good version of Band of Gold by Ronnie Dyson on his first LP , the Columbia LP entitled " If You Let Me Make Love To You... ".

It's more uptempo and more "northern" than Freda's original.

That LP also has Ronnie's turbo charged version of Little Willie John's " Fever " ....

[Epic]

Used to love hearing this in the 70s & 80s when the thicko mobile jock would play it at wedding receptions - don't think he actually listened to the words.

Closely followed by "Young Hearts Run Free" - can just see the tears of the brides mother rolling down her cheeks.

[SteveM]

I don't agree with you at all that it's "better than the brilliant original" - for a start, it IS the original, which the best known and chart topping version was edited down and remixed from - but the story is that, having cut it in the long format, H-D-H realised that it was a bit meandering, and that it lacked punch for radio play, so they cut out the unnnecessary 'bridge' and - from memory - a verse, replaced the weak intro with something a bit more punchy from elsewhere in the record, added some memorable backing vocals and generally made a good, 4 minute 'work in progress' record into a 2 1/2 minute amazing one.

Although it would have charted, I believe that it would never have become the hit that it was had it not undergone this major 'reconstructive surgery'.

It's been issued several times - indeed, I put it on a V/A Invictus compilation when I was running Sequel in the late 90s - but credit for unearthing it and, indeed, for issuing it first goes to Neil Rushton who put it out on the flip of a a gold vinyl Inferno reissue of the hit version of BOG, c. 1980....

Okay, better than the version that charted imo. And I've got that inferno version somewhere d'oh

[Sean Hampsey]

I only have the Invictus INV 502 Copy, anyone know the story behind the 533 release, it is the rarest number.

Hi Roger,

The 533 was issued in 1973 when distribution moved from Capitol (US) and EMI (UK) to Columbia (UK CBS) and they apparantly wihdrew it soon after... due to lack of interest.

Understandable really as "BOG" had been a huge seller on both sides of the pond only a couple of years earlier.

I had a copy up on eBay about a year ago for about £12... but didn't get any takers. Bizarre really given its scarcity, but I guess that some folk (most folk) didn't realise what it was I was advertising.

UK Collectors will certainly know how hard it is. Anything less than £25, in Mint Condition, would be a good price I'd say.

Sean

[45cellar]

Hi Roger,

The 533 was issued in 1973 when distribution moved from Capitol (US) and EMI (UK) to Columbia (UK CBS) and they apparantly wihdrew it soon after... due to lack of interest.

Understandable really as "BOG" had been a huge seller on both sides of the pond only a couple of years earlier.

I had a copy up on eBay about a year ago for about £12... but didn't get any takers. Bizarre really given its scarcity, but I guess that some folk (most folk) didn't realise what it was I was advertising.

UK Collectors will certainly know how hard it is. Anything less than £25, in Mint Condition, would be a good price I'd say.

Sean

Hi Sean

Thanks, I've often wondered what happened with the release and why It was withdrawn from sale.