Jump to content
Soul Source

Edward Hamilton

Posted

is the Mary Jane recording of I'm gonna love you the same as the Jameco recording, or is it the Carrie and Jameco the same?

thanks

adam

  • Replies 22
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Most active in this topic

Featured Replies

good question..i'll pull them and play and let you know..

Mary Jane not the same as Carrie,does that help.

  adamt said:
is the Mary Jane recording of I'm gonna love you the same as the Jameco recording, or is it the Carrie and Jameco the same?

thanks

adam

Edward Hamilton - I'm gonna love you 4 different versions.

CARRIE 6502 orange label time 2:25 SKRM-1078-1 mix

CARRIE 009 green label time 2:35 c#009b mix

JAMECO 2088 time 2:35 SKRM-1078-1B mix credits backing by The Fifes

all the above are different but only subtle differences.

Would suggest all taken at the same session.

MARY JANE 6707 time 2:30 credits the backing by The Arabians and is totally different: different vocals, instruments etc. Not recorded at the same session would suggest different musicians and vocal backing.

Hope that helps.. John

anyone spin the flip,call me bloody brill record,im gonna love you is right up there imho,my fav track BY HIM is willing mind,now thats a soul record.

BAZ A. :lol:

  Tedsoul said:
Carrie orange is the best version IMO and Call me your right Baz bloody brilliant

Can someone please post a soundfile of "IGLY" from orange Carrie?

  nordic soul said:
Can someone please post a soundfile of "IGLY" from orange Carrie?

I think the 2 posted from the orange i have just played mine and cant hear any difference

rog can you confirm

  Tedsoul said:
I think the 2 posted from the orange i have just played mine and cant hear any difference

rog can you confirm

Hi Ted

I will record my 3 copies and Identify which they came from later tonight.

I have been out Gardening and used the Refosoul file that Jumpin Joan Uploaded 13/10/2006

It is described as Mary Jane. :laugh: 

  45cellar said:

Hi Ted

I will record my 3 copies and Identify which they came from later tonight.

I have been out Gardening and used the Refosoul file that Jumpin Joan Uploaded 13/10/2006

It is described as Mary Jane. shades

Having listened again there might be a few diffderences but i will let you post them thumbsup.gif

Ted

Often heard people say the Mary Jane copies had a better punchier/cleaner sound to the other issues...not really sure myself as it's ages since I compared 'em, what I do like though is the extended fade on the Carrie(green) issue...just love the words Edward sings, a shame they're lost on the Mary Jane issue as they add so much to the record for me.

PS: I've often wondered about the name Mary Jane.....is it a reference to marijuana, or after Lou Beatty's wife/daughter?

Edited by DelTee

  DelTee said:
Often heard people say the MaryJane copies had a better punchier/cleaner sound to the other issues...not really sure myself as it's ages since I compared 'em, what I do like though is the extended fade on the Carrie(green) issue...just love the words Edward sings, a shame they're lost on the MaryJane issue as they add so much to the record for me.

the Orange Carrie are crisper and punchier

  Tedsoul said:
the Orange Carrie are crisper and punchier

Then it must be very punchy since the Mary Jane 45 is very loud and powerful.

  Tedsoul said:
the Orange Carrie are crisper and punchier

Ted are you sure??

just played the orange one..drum intro is weaker than the

Mary Jane take..

the backing group are stronger on the Mary Jane..although the Carrie backing has a real raw emotional appeal, which I like.

and I think Edward two/three year older vocal maybe stronger on the Mary Jane take..

only my opinion..

but I prefer the later Mary Jane reworking, especially the wonderful instrumental break and Eddie going off on one, with a lengthened and tortured "Yes I Will !!"

The Orange label instrumental break is not as spectualar in comparison..but orange copy is infinately rarer though, and has the good flipside of course.

Lets face it it's a damn good 45, which ever take you listen to.

  45cellar said:


Hi Ted

I will record my 3 copies and Identify which they came from later tonight.
I have been out Gardening and used the Refosoul file that Jumpin Joan Uploaded 13/10/2006
It is described as Mary Jane. shades.gif




It definitely is Mary Jane! thumbsup.gif

I think the Mary Jane version clinches it for me :elvis:

Just my two penny worth rolleyes.gif

Get involved with Soul Source

Go to topic listing

Advert via Google