Gasher Posted May 6, 2007 Posted May 6, 2007 (edited) £250-£300 mate one on ebay last week check out popsike last 2 went $502. $490.two diff label designs never seen an issue...does it exist???? regards gasher Edited May 6, 2007 by the gasher
Guest mark shepherd Posted May 6, 2007 Posted May 6, 2007 sold one (demo) a few months back , think the price was £300, then heard it played out and regretted the sale, ah well ho hum......
Guest Johnny Mack Posted May 12, 2007 Posted May 12, 2007 I recently bought the Jimmy Conwell LP on EBay on the basis it was the original and am waiting for this to arrive. Have 2 questions : 1) I didnt realize at the time that the album had been re-issued - how do I tell the two apart ? 2) Is the album track of Sundown in Watts the same cut or a different cut of the song - I certainly hear Jimmy's voice loud and clear on the Exits but havent actually heard the album track. Help appreciated. Thanks John
Alan T Posted May 12, 2007 Posted May 12, 2007 I recently bought the Jimmy Conwell LP on EBay on the basis it was the original and am waiting for this to arrive. Have 2 questions : 1) I didnt realize at the time that the album had been re-issued - how do I tell the two apart ? 2) Is the album track of Sundown in Watts the same cut or a different cut of the song - I certainly hear Jimmy's voice loud and clear on the Exits but havent actually heard the album track. Help appreciated. Thanks John It has been reissued but not sure how to tell the difference. A very strong album, not a bad track on it. I think Sundown is a slightly different mix, never really studied it but theres just something different. You'll be happy with your purchase and well worth the wait. Tomo
NEV Posted May 12, 2007 Posted May 12, 2007 sold one (demo) a few months back , think the price was £300, then heard it played out and regretted the sale, ah well ho hum...... Thought you would have learned your lesson by now Shep never mind , sure you'll get another if you really want one eh seeya at makam and takam land 2nite
Sunnysoul Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 (edited) I recently bought the Jimmy Conwell LP on EBay on the basis it was the original and am waiting for this to arrive. Have 2 questions : 1) I didnt realize at the time that the album had been re-issued - how do I tell the two apart ? 2) Is the album track of Sundown in Watts the same cut or a different cut of the song - I certainly hear Jimmy's voice loud and clear on the Exits but havent actually heard the album track. Help appreciated. Thanks John The Jimmy Conwell LP version of the tune is a more "modern" version (ie 70's sounding although still faithful to the original) but just as good as the Exits original. Prefer to play Jimmy Conwell when DJ ing. As for any re issue of the LP, over the years many collectors and dealers have in their sales banter often mentioned 're issues' or "bootlegs" of virtually all the various collectable LP's on Guinness such as Jimmy Conwell, Newban 1 & 2, Frank Dell, Roger Hatcher etc but I've NEVER ever seen a reissue or bootleg of ANY of those in 30 years! I'm happy to be corrected but I don't think ANY of the Guinness LPs have indeed EVER been re issued or bootlegged ... I've come to the conclusion that it's just an urban myth that there have been re issues/bootlegs of so many rare soul LP's. Unless , that is, the major "re issuer" Scorpio Records in the US has ever produced them (and they have done many by the way but none of the ones I just mentioned) ??? Or our Japanese friends ? But as I say, I'm happy to be corrected on this point . Perhaps Mr Manship can offer us his wisdom on re issued and bootlegged soul LP's ???? It's an area that needs a lot more experienced and educated comment. I WOULD like to have Mr Manship confirm whether for example whether the two Dysons Faces LPs really were re issued or bootlegged and if so how exactly do you tell the difference ??? And Gwen McCraes Melody of Life LP ??? Damn Sam the Miracle Man ??? Rhythm Machine ??? and so on and so on ... And lets not forget the clear distinction between a RE ISSUE and a BOOTLEG , reissue means a legitimate licensed second issue of an LP often with a company logo like Charly inserted on the sleeve design. A bootleg is a deliberate illegal, attempted note for note reproduction of the original LP ? Edited May 13, 2007 by sunnysoul
Guest Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 £250-£300 mate one on ebay last week check out popsike last 2 went $502. $490.two diff label designs never seen an issue...does it exist???? regards gasher yes Richie it was issued I've had & sold a black stock copy
Guest Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 The Jimmy Conwell LP version of the tune is a more "modern" version (ie 70's sounding although still faithful to the original) but just as good as the Exits original. Prefer to play Jimmy Conwell when DJ ing. As for any re issue of the LP, over the years many collectors and dealers have in their sales banter often mentioned 're issues' or "bootlegs" of virtually all the various collectable LP's on Guinness such as Jimmy Conwell, Newban 1 & 2, Frank Dell, Roger Hatcher etc but I've NEVER ever seen a reissue or bootleg of ANY of those in 30 years! I'm happy to be corrected but I don't think ANY of the Guinness LPs have indeed EVER been re issued or bootlegged ... I've come to the conclusion that it's just an urban myth that there have been re issues/bootlegs of so many rare soul LP's. Unless , that is, the major "re issuer" Scorpio Records in the US has ever produced them (and they have done many by the way but none of the ones I just mentioned) ??? Or our Japanese friends ? But as I say, I'm happy to be corrected on this point . Perhaps Mr Manship can offer us his wisdom on re issued and bootlegged soul LP's ???? It's an area that needs a lot more experienced and educated comment. I WOULD like to have Mr Manship confirm whether for example whether the two Dysons Faces LPs really were re issued or bootlegged and if so how exactly do you tell the difference ??? And Gwen McCraes Melody of Life LP ??? Damn Sam the Miracle Man ??? Rhythm Machine ??? and so on and so on ... And lets not forget the clear distinction between a RE ISSUE and a BOOTLEG , reissue means a legitimate licensed second issue of an LP often with a company logo like Charly inserted on the sleeve design. A bootleg is a deliberate illegal, attempted note for note reproduction of the original LP ? your quote "WOULD like to have Mr Manship confirm whether for example whether the two Dysons Faces LPs really were re issued or bootlegged. LP reissues are something I've not documented anything like i have the 45s .. I will of course do it..but to have both boot & legit releases in stock at any one time is usual..I've documented Skull Snaps LP etc but not the ones you've mentioned so far. your quote "A bootleg is a deliberate illegal, attempted note for note reproduction of the original LP ?" Lets not forget the COUNTERFEIT that is made then sold as the original to decieve and gain from..they are the ones that niggle me...Z.Z. & Company, Oxford Knights etc the list is endless.. but it's hard to say what was legal and what was not. Simon Soussan often credited the "Licensed from" on his repro labels.. and of course now legendary licensed from "Toller licensing" has apparently confused a legit record company owner friend of mine... It's minefield.. of what was right and what was wrong..but i do try to fully document anything i find "questionable" but at the mo' and can't help you on the LPs. I'm sure Steve Plumb or someone else will have a better answer as they handle this area more than I do. PS Guinness are I believe a totally legit label.
Sutty Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 (edited) I WOULD like to have Mr Manship confirm whether for example whether the two Dysons Faces LPs really were re issued or bootlegged and if so how exactly do you tell the difference ??? And Gwen McCraes Melody of Life LP ??? Damn Sam the Miracle Man ??? Rhythm Machine ??? and so on and so on ... whether they were bootlegs or reissues, gwen mcrae, both dysons faces and jimmy conwell have been reissued as i have owned them all. i believe jimmy conwell lp was a jap one, it may have even had blues interactions or the like at the bottom of the sleeve or label. 'melody of life' was repressed a few years back as a look-a-like, you can tell from the sheen on the label it's not an original, rhythym machine is definitely a reissue/boot. dysons faces are well known as being reissued, and have just been reissued again only last week. cheers Sutty Edited May 13, 2007 by Sutty
Guest Johnny Mack Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 Sunnysoul I appreciate the heads up on this. This is a special LP - in particular I'm looking forward to hearing the JC version of The Jades cut on Imperial - was a little disappointed to see the same LP featuring on a UK list at GBP 10 advertised as a re-issue, though. The LP market is one that rarely gets discussed on this forum, but there are certainly re-issues around. I have more than a couple of funk LP's which have seen a second release - two that immediately spring to mind ,that I bought as new releases at the time are Howard Andrews Congregation, great Bay Area album - and Reuben Wilson's LP on Cadet - both of which have been re-issued. There are a couple of outlets that specialize in these LP's - Skullsnaps, Milton Wright, Joe Quarterman, Queenie Lyons, Baby Huey, Marlena Shaw - all quality products on hd vinyl - however I have no idea as to whether they are paying their dues. Bearing in mind the litigious nature of business within the USA I'd guess that these must be legitimate re-releases. Anyone else have any thoughts on this ? Joihn The Jimmy Conwell LP version of the tune is a more "modern" version (ie 70's sounding although still faithful to the original) but just as good as the Exits original. Prefer to play Jimmy Conwell when DJ ing. As for any re issue of the LP, over the years many collectors and dealers have in their sales banter often mentioned 're issues' or "bootlegs" of virtually all the various collectable LP's on Guinness such as Jimmy Conwell, Newban 1 & 2, Frank Dell, Roger Hatcher etc but I've NEVER ever seen a reissue or bootleg of ANY of those in 30 years! I'm happy to be corrected but I don't think ANY of the Guinness LPs have indeed EVER been re issued or bootlegged ... I've come to the conclusion that it's just an urban myth that there have been re issues/bootlegs of so many rare soul LP's. Unless , that is, the major "re issuer" Scorpio Records in the US has ever produced them (and they have done many by the way but none of the ones I just mentioned) ??? Or our Japanese friends ? But as I say, I'm happy to be corrected on this point . Perhaps Mr Manship can offer us his wisdom on re issued and bootlegged soul LP's ???? It's an area that needs a lot more experienced and educated comment. I WOULD like to have Mr Manship confirm whether for example whether the two Dysons Faces LPs really were re issued or bootlegged and if so how exactly do you tell the difference ??? And Gwen McCraes Melody of Life LP ??? Damn Sam the Miracle Man ??? Rhythm Machine ??? and so on and so on ... And lets not forget the clear distinction between a RE ISSUE and a BOOTLEG , reissue means a legitimate licensed second issue of an LP often with a company logo like Charly inserted on the sleeve design. A bootleg is a deliberate illegal, attempted note for note reproduction of the original LP ?
Gasher Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 NICE ONE JOHN THANKS FOR THE CONFIRMATION ID LIKE ONE OF THOSE BABYS yes Richie it was issued I've had & sold a black stock copy
Garethx Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 (edited) Another giveaway for the Gwen McCrae "re-issue" is the construction of the sleeve, and the quality of board used in the sleeve. The original is of "slick" construction: ie printed paper glued to unprinted heavy board, whereas the bootleg is printed board glued in one piece. Hope this makes sense. Just who is behind these re-issues? My guess is that no proper recompense is being arranged with the true rights holders and the enterprise is a license to print money. Very naughty in the instances where bootlegs are sold at the same price as originals. Edited May 19, 2007 by garethx
Guest Posted May 13, 2007 Posted May 13, 2007 Another giveaway for the Gwen McCrae "re-issue" is the construction of the sleeve, and the quality of board used in the sleeve. The original is a of "slick" construction: ie printed paper glued to unprinted heavy board, whereas the bootleg is printed board glued in one piece. Hope this makes sense. Just who is behind these re-issues? My guess is that no proper recompense is being arranged with the true rights holders and the enterprise is license to print money. Very naughty in the instances where bootlegs are sold at the same price as originals. This series of LP reissues covered just about every collectable SOUL LP in the late 90s and were in every shop in the USA I ever visited. I think the companies (Universal etc) cashed in on this one having the rights. They are genuine reissues and used all the original artwork. Yes, the sleeve are the easy giveaway to the 2nd. press as they were in much thinner card without the 70s "grain"..
Recommended Posts
Get involved with Soul Source
Add your comments now
Join Soul Source
A free & easy soul music affair!
Join Soul Source now!Log in to Soul Source
Jump right back in!
Log in now!