Compared To What - Guy Hennigan ?

[Martin L]

Hoping for  some assistance please 

Guy played a version of Compared To What on Dean Andersons sound of soul show a few months back    and i have  been trying to locate the Artist      does anyone know the artist it was a very funky fast version  i seem to remember the lady was european    ???

 

Many thanks in anticipation 

 

Martin L x 

[Tony Turner]

22 minutes ago, Martin L said:

Hoping for  some assistance please 

Guy played a version of Compared To What on Dean Andersons sound of soul show a few months back    and i have  been trying to locate the Artist      does anyone know the artist it was a very funky fast version  i seem to remember the lady was european    ???

 

Many thanks in anticipation 

 

Martin L x 

It's Stefanie Vhynak

[Martin L]

Thank you   Tony 

 

 

[Paul-s]

Ursula von der Leyen    

[Peter99]

It's awful. But, I guess "let's play it because it's not well known" syndrome. 

Peter

[Simon T]

Nowt wrong with that. follow it up with some Shocking Blue- Venus

[Geeselad]

Babe too!

 

 

 

[Kathryn Magson]

On 08/09/2024 at 18:39, Peter99 said:

It's awful. But, I guess "let's play it because it's not well known" syndrome. 

Peter

I'll second that one Peter - it gets a thumbs down from me too!

[John Hart]

A much covered tune , 50 Plus versions, written by the "Winner"  Gene Mc Daniels. Checkout Ray Charles 1980 take  issued in US , Europe & UK on 45," Compared to Stef ",,,rather good methinks ?

[Mike]

says 250 + covers here

 

loads of quality covers though out there imo, many with different approaches, making it hard to pick a definite one?

can clock a great live version here

grab a brew though as its 8 mins long!

[Peter99]

23 minutes ago, Mike said:

says 250 + covers here

 

loads of quality covers though out there imo, many with different approaches, making it hard to pick a definite one?

can clock a great live version here

grab a brew though as its 8 mins long!

That's a very cool video - nice jazzy version. Being an old stick in the mud it would take something to steer me away from Mr Floods party - superb dance track. That's the one I was brought up on. 

Peter

[Geeselad]

Agree that Mr flood's is hard to beat for northern dancefloors, Les McCann has to be the definitive version for me. 

[Modularman]

Della Reese has a pretty good punt at the song

 

Edited September 14 by Modularman

[Keamus]

Do like this take on the standard

 

 

[Davace]

Agree Floods is a great dancer and McCann has  a  great groove.When picking up the McCann 45 on Atlantic I was horrified to hear the sound effect beeps...spoiled it for me.

[Soul Shrews]

6 hours ago, Mike said:

says 250 + covers here

 

loads of quality covers though out there imo, many with different approaches, making it hard to pick a definite one?

can clock a great live version here

grab a brew though as its 8 mins long!

Best version for me.

I have a promo copy of the LP where one af the lyrics is bleeped out. Stock copy plays as normal.

Also like Roberta Flacks version

Cheers Paul

[Geeselad]

On 14/09/2024 at 14:26, Davace said:

Agree Floods is a great dancer and McCann has  a  great groove.When picking up the McCann 45 on Atlantic I was horrified to hear the sound effect beeps...spoiled it for me.

Going to check mine now, haven't played the 7 in years. 

[Robbk]

I like Les McCann's original version best.  It was a big hit on KGFJ and KDIA, and they only played the very best fast and mid-tempo Jazz instrumentals. They stayed away from slow, bluesy instrumentals.  Eddie Harris' version was played and charted nicely, too.  I think WVON and WBEE played them in Chicago, too.  I was really big on Blue Note and Atlantic Jazz at that time, as well as Afro-Latin Jazz.  Luckily, very few of the Soul collectors were competition for me -especially  for the 45s.  Getting mint Jazz LPs for discount rates , or mint DJ LPs at thrift stores or in bargain bins was much tougher.  Funny thing, I'm the only one I ever knew who generally liked the shorter marketing 45s' 3 minute versions of Jazz LP title and featured songs, than the 5 to 10 minute album versions.  The compact 45 versions were much more structured and thus, to me, tighter.  The much longer LP versions rambled all over the place, and often had enough time to have a slot for a long solo for each major instrument with a lot of improvisational wandering away from the general track of the song. (which many, many, if not most Jazz fans like).  And I do appreciate them; but I like the tighter, structured tunes much more.  After all, who wants to listen to 9 straight minutes of only drums, while waiting, hopelessly, for the music to come back?????!!!  

Edited September 19 by Robbk

[Smudger]

11 hours ago, Robbk said:

I like Les McCann's original version best.  It was a big hit on KGFJ and KDIA, and they only played the very best fast and mid-tempo Jazz instrumentals. They stayed away from slow, bluesy instrumentals.  Eddie Harris' version was played and charted nicely, too.  I think WVON and WBEE played them in Chicago, too.  I was really big on Blue Note and Atlantic Jazz at that time, as well as Afro-Latin Jazz.  Luckily, very few of the Soul collectors were competition for me -especially  for the 45s.  Getting mint Jazz LPs for discount rates , or mint DJ LPs at thrift stores or in bargain bins was much tougher.  Funny thing, I'm the only one I ever knew who generally liked the shorter marketing 45s' 3 minute versions of Jazz LP title and featured songs, than the 5 to 10 minute album versions.  The compact 45 versions were much more structured and thus, to me, tighter.  The much longer LP versions rambled all over the place, and often had enough time to have a slot for a long solo for each major instrument with a lot of improvisational wandering away from the general track of the song. (which many, many, if not most Jazz fans like).  And I do appreciate them; but I like the tighter, structured tunes much more.  After all, who wants to listen to 9 straight minutes of only drums, while waiting, hopelessly, for the music to come back?????!!!  

I bought the original 45,the demo and a test pressing to try and get one without that annoying bleep .To no avail

[Kesalocasoul]

On 14/09/2024 at 13:15, Keamus said:

Do like this take on the standard

 

 

I like this version, nice to hear the kalimba being played; brings back memories of when I lived in Tanzania.

Here's a Philly/Jazz take by Billy Paul from his Going East album (1971), blending it with a raft of other songs towards the end.

 

[Mike]

v recent remix

Compared to What (Remix) (feat. Terri Lyne Carrington, Angela Davis and Kassa Overall)

say an interesting take but doubt if will go back to it