Personal review, new Top 500 book.

[Quinvy]

I’ve had the opportunity to view the new version of this book recently. 
I thought that I would give you my unbiased opinion, in case you’re thinking of buying a copy.
The original was an interesting read, in that it’s just one person’s opinion on our favourite music. The scans weren’t the best, (black & white)and it was difficult to locate a particular record without trawling through the pages.
The new version however is much better in this respect. Colour scans, and an alphabetical index make this a useful reference book, and ideal for your record room or coffee table.
You won’t agree with the writers choices.
Our scene has become so diverse that would be impossible to achieve a universally accepted top 500. 
I was pleased to see a rare top 500 is also included in the book. You probably won’t agree with this either, but it is interesting and a welcome addition to the book. The only disappointment is that not all the rare records have label scans included.
Personally, I would have preferred that to some of the “filler” pictures and top tens etc.
All in all, I think it’s well worth buying. Interesting and a decent reference book.
Recommended ****

[princemono]

I agree with most of your review except your point about the alphabetical index being a useful reference.

True everything is in alphabetical order BUT WITH NO REFERENCE TO PAGE NUMBERS, so basically

of no use at all. This was not the case with previous versions of this otherwise fine book.

anyone know if this was intentional.