Poll: Version Battle - Wide Awake In A Dream

[Mike]

A version battle suggested by Chris aka  @Chris Turnbull

'Wide awake in a dream’

Jerry Jackson
Philip James
Vicki Anderson
Lynn Collins

For this 'battle' return, there are four versions of this great song to think about, as before if you wish to take part all you have to do is have a think/listen and then simply select your choice via the poll

and as the idea behind this and similar posts is to get some talk going, make sure that once voted you post up your thoughts/reasons etc behind ya choice as well

 

Jerry Jackson

 

Philip James

 

Vicki Anderson

 

 

Lynn Collins

 

 

[Mal C]

Oooo thats not easy at all... another 'Turnbull' terror of a choice!

Edited May 24, 2022 by Mal C

[Amsterdam Russ]

Jerry Jackson for me. In fact, I'd rate them in exactly the order they're listed.

Phillips James's version is very good, but as Dobie Gray sang... the original is still the greatest.

[Soul16]

Jerry Jackson for me too, it has more 'bite'. I also generally favour male vocals over female for some reason, not sure why.

[Westender]

Jackson or Collins for me. Think they have the fuller, more interesting arrangements. 

Collins delivers a good performance and the whole thing is very nicely put together, but i'm going with Jackson for his well judged vocal, the very interesting vocal harmony arrangement and those vibes!

[Wally Francis]

Collins for me, a nice snappy arrangement and I lean towards the 70's more these day's.

[Skegsoul]

Have got all of them but Philip James for me used to hammer it back in the day off the lp. All good mind

[Twinroots]

Philip James & blues busters for me...stunning island soul...just has everything

[Phil Shields]

Philip James for me simply the best

[El Corol]

2 hours ago, Skegsoul said:

Have got all of them but Philip James for me used to hammer it back in the day off the lp. All good mind

Was that the “Independent Jamaica” LP? where it’s credited to The Maytals, which as I understand is really Phillip James version slowed/ pitched down slightly? Or is it another LP?

[Soul Shrews]

Vicki Anderson for me. Love her voice and those punchy horns !

[Skegsoul]

23 minutes ago, El Corol said:

Was that the “Independent Jamaica” LP? where it’s credited to The Maytals, which as I understand is really Phillip James version slowed/ pitched down slightly? Or is it another LP?

Is off the Blues busters " Behold how sweet it is" lp on sunshine.

[Skegsoul]

21 minutes ago, Skegsoul said:

Is off the Blues busters " Behold how sweet it is" lp on sunshine.

[Shinehead]

Jerry , then Vicki for me. 

[Tomangoes]

Love to hear a Roy Hamilton version...

JJ has it for the boys and VA for the girls.

Ed

[Chris Turnbull]

10 hours ago, Mal C said:

Oooo thats not easy at all... another 'Turnbull' terror of a choice!

 yeah not easy at all Mal - I'd go for either of the two male versions I think but hard to choose between them - played JJ more over the years so probably edges it over PJ, but very close - PJ a favourite current spin 

[The Yank]

I would go with the Jerry Jackson version.

     There's also a remake  by Barry Biggs - 

 

Edited May 24, 2022 by The Yank

[Tlscapital]

The Vicky Anderson ALL THE WAY for me but the later 1969 "warmer" remix on King instead of the earlier 1966 De Luxe "colder" mix like on the YT sound bit up here.

Knew the Blues Busters first as a teen. OK-ish. Was into the Jamaican music back then and like most them folks had not much appreciation for their "soul" acts. To this day still.

The Jerry Jackson is first but the guy never had too much going for my soul thirst. A good crooner with corky commercial musical arrangements. All a tad too much for my liking or wallet.

Keeping a Lynn Collins because it's worth peanuts and doesn't hurt to stay there. Taking this tragedy of a song to another level of derision of some sort. Gets a spin home every turn of the century.

Edited May 24, 2022 by Tlscapital

[Tlscapital]

Looked out for a 1969 'King' remix/version on YT but all are the De Luxe 1966 mix. Only found this one that was made in my dear old country Belgium by and for the 'Pop-Corn' people with a so slightly over-pitched recording of it but not by much if ever. Voilà...

 

Edited May 25, 2022 by Tlscapital

[Midnight Drifter]

Tough one but Vicky made it in my case.. I like the overall production, the final product so to speak, a bit more than the others..

[Okehsoul1952]

Vicky Anderson for me, all day long....followed by Jerry Jackson. Lynn Collins is my least favourite!

[Guest]

11 hours ago, The Yank said:

I would go with the Jerry Jackson version.

     There's also a remake  by Barry Biggs - 

 

On the poll I went for Vicki Anderson as the most soulful and for the horn arrangement.

Midnight Drifter - I have a lovely memory of a hot summer's night Blues Party in S London in 1981 (they did happen honest) dancing or maybe swaying with a lovely woman to the Barry Biggs 12" version with it's great sax solo. Music is about memory so that version will always be my favourite. Thanks for uploading.

BTW - Biggs has just reissued his Lovers rock albums. I've all ready bought them. 

 

 

 

Edited May 25, 2022 by Dukeburgundy

[Soul Shrews]

17 hours ago, Tlscapital said:

The Vicky Anderson ALL THE WAY for me but the later 1969 "warmer" remix on King instead of the earlier 1966 De Luxe "colder" mix like on the YT sound bit up here.

 

Aaah I didn't need to listen to the clip as I have the King version so assumed that was it.

Thanks for the info Tim !

Not changing my vote, lovely voice punchy horns and now warm too ! Lovely

[Midnight Drifter]

7 hours ago, Dukeburgundy said:

On the poll I went for Vicki Anderson as the most soulful and for the horn arrangement.

Midnight Drifter - I have a lovely memory of a hot summer's night Blues Party in S London in 1981 (they did happen honest) dancing or maybe swaying with a lovely woman to the Barry Biggs 12" version with it's great sax solo. Music is about memory so that version will always be my favourite. Thanks for uploading.

BTW - Biggs has just reissued his Lovers rock albums. I've all ready bought them. 

 

 

 

It wasn't me uploading it but your description of that dance you went to sounds great  

[Tricky]

Vicky Anderson for me and I like and have both versions.