Poll: Version Battle - I Watched You Slowly Slip Away

[Mike]

Suggested by @Dave Moore , this time around we have two versions of 'I Watched You Slowly Slip Away' climbing into the ring

 

Howard Guyton -  I watched You Slowly Slip Away

 

 

Lou Courtney - Watched You Slowly Slip Away

 

Could do with some fresh suggestions for the 'battle' list, so if you do have then as always feel free to pm me them

Going for a week long poll for this one, so need to be quick in voicing your choice and posting your take

 

 

[Scootboy]

Howard Guyton does it better for me



[Modularman]

Howard Guyton for me too, a much more interesting arrangement IMO

[Missing Link]

They're both great versions but I think the slightly slower tempo of Howard Guyton suits the song better. Teddy Randazzo's arrangement and production is also superior.

[Bbrich]

I like the faster Lou version,  the way he belts the song out.

[Guest Spain pete]

Howard with The magic of teddy

[Woodbutcher]

With Mr Randazzo at the controls there can only be one winner of this one ... 

[The Yank]

Howard for me too !! 

[Winsford Soul]

Can only be  Howard Guyton for me. So many memories.  Remember it costing me £30 for a water damaged label  verve issue.

Steve 

[Wicked]

Gotta be Howard.

[John A]

Apart from the title line, they're not even the same song.. but side by side then Howard is miles better.

Edited November 1, 2018 by John A

[Soul16]

Howard Guyton is the better version I reckon. Great intro, great vocals and an instrumental break that pins you to the wall. Even the sound quality on the 45 is top notch. A true Northern belter if ever there was one.

[Davenpete]

I watched you SLOWLY slip away belted out is a bit of an oxymoron to me - Howard Guyton all the way.

Dx

[Ian Stacey]

Howard Guyton  play it out at nuneaton these last couple of years 

[Kev John]

Lou  for me 

Bert Decoteaux  arranged & conducted  what more to want !

 

[Daved]

Good one. Howard G for me. Reminds of Alan H's set at These Old Shoes about 18 years ago.

[Mike]

all over now

as you can read below quite a one sided result with Howard getting the most selections

 

 
Poll: Version Battle - I Watched You Slowly Slip Away
I Watched You Slowly Slip Away  
This poll is closed to new votes

1. Which version does it for you?
Howard Guyton
91%
Lou Courtney
9%
 

thanks to all who took part

the next one be up soon!