Just purchased a copy of "Hook Line and Sinker" on Mica for a friend. Looking in the price guide this tune is also on Vick, as is his other recording "you change my whole life around"

So, I would imagine that the Vick recording is the original? So what is the Mica release?

A boot, a reissue?

I have also been informed that the two releases are different takes of "Hook line and sinker"?

Anyone have a sound file of the Vick release? It must be a pretty rare 45?

Any information would be appreciated. Thanks.

Is the Mica one the one with I Can't Please You on the other side - cos that's an alternate take as well.

Yes, that's the one Pete.

Mica copy is an original

so ive been led to believe/ive got one in my playbox

The Vick copy of HLS hasn't been known for more than a few years, haven't heard it so I don't know if it is different to the Mica release, which is what it was originally played from by Guy H.

Any ways both labels were Bob Lee concerns.

had the vick release in my hand on saturday night, is there interest in this

track at the mo? seen a few wants and a couple for sale lately, whats a realistic price on the mica release

thought about £75?

must admit i really like the jimmy robins take on the flip, sounds really raw!

russ

Some one on here had one in sales for 150!

Yes the JR on the flip is a bit different to the other releases.

  On 02/05/2012 at 16:50, Tony Smith said:

The Vick copy of HLS hasn't been known for more than a few years, haven't heard it so I don't know if it is different to the Mica release, which is what it was originally played from by Guy H.

Any ways both labels were Bob Lee concerns.

Ah, thanks Tony, that explains why nobody seems to know about the Vick release. Even Tim Brown has never had it.

  On 02/05/2012 at 16:50, Tony Smith said:

The Vick copy of HLS hasn't been known for more than a few years, haven't heard it so I don't know if it is different to the Mica release, which is what it was originally played from by Guy H.

Any ways both labels were Bob Lee concerns.

just spoken to carl fortnum can confirm that the vick release is the same as the mica, very rare on vick, carl as had his copy since the 80s never seen another!!

value of the vick release????? jms says £200, which is based on carls copy which scan also appears on rarest of the rare

interesting stuff

Phil , if you go to GRUMPY on the 17th May I'll show you the ROY WRIGHT on VICK and I'll bring along TONI ROSS on HARTOWN .

regards pumpkinseed .

SORRY NOT 17th THATS THURSDAY SATURDAY........19th

  On 02/05/2012 at 13:29, keithw said:

Mica copy is an original

so ive been led to believe/ive got one in my playbox

Me too!

Phil, theres a thread in sharp end on the James Robbins here:

ROY WRIGHT - HOOK LINE AND SINKER / SOMETHING IS WRONG ( VICK RECORDS 210 ) RED LABEL / BLACK PRINT same design as " you changed my whole life around " .

Sell it Carl....sell em all

  On 02/05/2012 at 20:25, pumpkinseed said:

Phil , if you go to GRUMPY on the 17th May I'll show you the ROY WRIGHT on VICK and I'll bring along TONI ROSS on HARTOWN .

regards pumpkinseed .

Is the sound quality on the Tony Ross very poor Carl, I mean Pumpkin Seed........sorry.

IT COULD BE A LITTLE BETTER I THINK MR TONY SMITH WHO I PURCHASED IT OFF USED TO PLAY IT ON A OLD WIND UP GRAMOPHONE .

They're 'all' the same Carl, trust me

See you in a couple of weeks

  On 03/05/2012 at 20:21, pumpkinseed said:

IT COULD BE A LITTLE BETTER I THINK MR TONY SMITH WHO I PURCHASED IT OFF USED TO PLAY IT ON A OLD WIND UP GRAMOPHONE .

.and that was exactly how it was when it arrived with me, maybe it was Guy's stereogram?

ATB

T

  On 02/05/2012 at 20:23, russoul1 said:

just spoken to carl fortnum can confirm that the vick release is the same as the mica, very rare on vick, carl as had his copy since the 80s never seen another!!

value of the vick release????? jms says £200, which is based on carls copy which scan also appears on rarest of the rare

interesting stuff

Didn't JM auction one last year?

Mica was owned and run by Al Benson, who sometimes used Bob Lee as a producer.  Vick was owned by Bob Lee and Ruth Moore.  I believe Vick was regionally distributed along with other Bob Lee labels and Leo Austell's labels, including Renee, Sta-Set, Con-Duc, Mar-Jan, Hawk, Jerhart, and others.  Mica had no connection other than independent producer, Bob Lee, working for both.  Mica was related to Crash, Glow-Star and The Blues, as they were all owned by Benson during 1965-67.