Topics Closed On Site

[Mike]

just so all aware

as always every one who starts a topic can close it or reopen at any time on here

(if mods do it usually post up a note why)

if things are getting heated then do suggest take it to pm's (or the playground )

as sometimes a bit of banter between two can be taken different ways by others

on previous discussion did think meself was a good un, and hopefully Petes just shut it for things to calm down a bit

Edited November 8, 2005 by mike-

[Dave]

just so all aware

as always every one who starts a topic can close it or reopen at any time on here

(if mods do it usually post up a note why)

if things are getting heated then do suggest take it to pm's (or the playground )

as sometimes a bit of banter between two can be taken different ways by others

on previous discussion did think meself was a good un, and hopefully Petes just shut it for things to calm down a bit

Thanks for putting us in the picture Mike.

Hope he reopens it, as apart from the abuse, there were some interesting points being raised

[Guest Baz]

Thanks for putting us in the picture Mike.

Hope he reopens it, as apart from the abuse, there were some interesting points being raised

Agreed apart from some of the abuse, was a healthy disscussion, quite an enjoyable one at that

[Guest]

I agree Dave, I'm gutted this topic closed.. it was a fantastic avenue depicting everyones reasonable arguements about snobby soul

I must add though, someone that diss'd George Lemons, Fascinating Girl... I have just spend the last half hour between my key board and my conservatory floor dancing my ass off to this. Listen deep guys.. the lyrics are fab and the upkey vocals are out of this world

[Winnie :-)]

Agreed apart from some of the abuse, was a healthy disscussion, quite an enjoyable one at that

============

Can't believe the topics been closed, was starting to enjoy it. I did think Pete had a point though, some of the posts were abusive towards him and all he did was answer them.....and without swearing as well.

Hate "The feeling is real" and "fascinating girl", nothing to them for me. Also not keen on that 2x2 as I think it's a bit messy.

Win:-)

[Mandy]

I agree Dave, I'm gutted this topic closed.. it was a fantastic avenue depicting everyones reasonable arguements about snobby soul

I must add though, someone that diss'd George Lemons, Fascinating Girl... I have just spend the last half hour between my key board and my conservatory floor dancing my ass off to this. Listen deep guys.. the lyrics are fab and the upkey vocals are out of this world

Karen!!!! This is the first and last time I'll disagree with you .... George Lemons is shite

[Winnie :-)]

I agree Dave, I'm gutted this topic closed.. it was a fantastic avenue depicting everyones reasonable arguements about snobby soul

I must add though, someone that diss'd George Lemons, Fascinating Girl... I have just spend the last half hour between my key board and my conservatory floor dancing my ass off to this. Listen deep guys.. the lyrics are fab and the upkey vocals are out of this world

==========

Spent half an hour trying to wake yourself up It's the sort of record vegetarians would like

Just my opinion Karen, each to their own as someone said earlier

Winnie;)

[Guest]

Mandy.. really, put some headphone on, wack up the volume and feel it babe! Really, it fantastico, and I really am a soul snob LOL.

I think for me it's the up bit of the vocals that do it for me

[Guest garv]

just so all aware

as always every one who starts a topic can close it or reopen at any time on here

(if mods do it usually post up a note why)

if things are getting heated then do suggest take it to pm's (or the playground )

as sometimes a bit of banter between two can be taken different ways by others

on previous discussion did think meself was a good un, and hopefully Petes just shut it for things to calm down a bit

Thanks for that ..........i got confused there

Mike/ Lizards............ just out of interest how do you close a topic down???................

[Guest]

Isn't the Author close thread option a bit blaze?

[steve z]

Isn't the Author close thread option a bit blaze?

ONLY IF NEAR THE TRUTH Steve Z

[Winnie :-)]

Isn't the Author close thread option a bit blaze?

============

In fairness, Pete had just been warned on list. If he's not allowed to put his point of view across, he might as well close the topic IMO.

Winnie:-)

[Guest]

Meaning Steve? Come on, say it as it is

[Winnie :-)]

ONLY IF NEAR THE TRUTH Steve Z

============

Think you've got x-file syndrome.....exactly what truth were we nearing?

Winnie;-)

[steve z]

============

Think you've got x-file syndrome.....exactly what truth were we nearing?

Winnie;-)

This is totally unfair on Pete 'cos he is who is.Ask Pete who he is.Steve

[Guest]

============

Think you've got x-file syndrome.....exactly what truth were we nearing?

Winnie;-)

I dont do X files, I do say it as it is I have built my very reputation on that LOL.. Ask Mike

[Winnie :-)]

This is totally unfair on Pete 'cos he is who is.Ask Pete who he is.Steve

=============

Yep, that's cleared it up

I still haven't got a clue what you're on about, why am I being unfair on Pete? And what is the truth we were nearing?

Winnie:-)

[Winnie :-)]

I dont do X files, I do say it as it is I have built my very reputation on that LOL.. Ask Mike

===========

I don't doubt you tell it as it is Karen, but if you look the x-files reference was to Steve Z who mysteriously told us "ONLY IF NEAR THE TRUTH", which I thought had a certain Moulder/Scully sort of feel to it.

Winnie;-)

[steve z]

=============

Yep, that's cleared it up

I still haven't got a clue what you're on about, why am I being unfair on Pete? And what is the truth we were nearing?

Winnie:-)

At the extreme risk of assuming the last two replies are "aimed " at me Please ask Pete-S why he posts contentious issues,rather than ones "we" would have fun with Only kidding Pete

[Mike]

Thanks for that ..........i got confused there

Mike/ Lizards............ just out of interest how do you close a topic down???................

if you started it up it should show in the bottom left bit of thread off top of me head

dont really like discusing discussion but .....

in this case as it reads to me,

think was usual case of all posts can be read many ways but usually not the way the author intended

throw in different various styles of posting and the fact people are passionate about their music, then always good chance topics gonna get heated espically when two styles of posting collide

hard to draw a line just when bit of banter crosses into abuse

all can suggest is that people just take time out if feel have a urge to take it up a notch or kick off

mike

Edited November 9, 2005 by mike-

[Guest]

===========

I don't doubt you tell it as it is Karen, but if you look the x-files reference was to Steve Z who mysteriously told us "ONLY IF NEAR THE TRUTH", which I thought had a certain Moulder/Scully sort of feel to it.

Winnie;-)

No, really, I do say it how it is.. that's why everyone hates me LOL.. Cast your mind back... remember the Nauseating Bimbo who shouldn't ever grace the soul scene? That's me

Hehehe

Who gives a twopenny bit? We're still here Winnie, bolstering what we believe in.. that's cool.

[steve z]

I dont do X files, I do say it as it is I have built my very reputation on that LOL.. Ask Mike

Who is MIke?..........only kidding I haven't a reputation .............only a few tunes..oldies mainly .....Steve

[Winnie :-)]

At the extreme risk of assuming the last two replies are "aimed " at me Please ask Pete-S why he posts contentious issues,rather than ones "we" would have fun with Only kidding Pete

============

I know why Pete posts the sort of thing he does.....because the scene does come across as snobbish at times, particularly from within. Some of the records mentioned in his thread have nothing to do with northern, but over the years have been force fed to the N/S community IMO because of their rarity. I don't agree with him about all his choices, but surely most can see where he' s coming from.

I asked in a recent thread why, when inducting new people into the soul scene we invariably play them something up tempo, and considered an oldie. Never got a reply (as far as I can remember) but would you really play someone new "The feeling is real" to explain northern? I think the only thing Pete ever does is stand his corner, and promote his choice/style of northern, and personally I don't see anything wrong with that.

Winnie:-)

[Guest]

I could just snog you LOL... please don't derogitarily reply, let me hold that thought

Seriously, as Mike say's, passion comes from many an angle, something you cannot quantify nor qualify.. it's personal and it .... you know what I mean

if you started it up it should show in the bottom left bit of thread off top of me head

dont really like discusing discussion but .....

in this case as it reads to me,

think was usual case of all posts can be read many ways but usually not the way the author intended

throw in different various styles of posting and the fact people are passionate about their music, then always good chance topics gonna get heated espically when two styles of posting collide

hard to draw a line just when bit of banter crosses into abuse

all can suggest is that people just take time out if feel have a urge to take it up a notch or kick off

mike

Edited November 9, 2005 by Soulgirl

[Guest garv]

if you started it up it should show in the bottom left bit of thread off top of me head

dont really like discusing discussion but .....

in this case as it reads to me,

think was usual case of all posts can be read many ways but usually not the way the author intended

throw in different various styles of posting and the fact people are passionate about their music, then always good chance topics gonna get heated espically when two styles of posting collide

hard to draw a line just when bit of banter crosses into abuse

all can suggest is that people just take time out if feel have a urge to take it up a notch or kick off

mike

Cheers for that , i did`t mean to question why the topic was closed just the way to do it, for future reference.

[Mike]

Cheers for that , i did`t mean to question why the topic was closed just the way to do it, for future reference.

nah tagged last bit on in reply to some posts

discussing discussion ack!

[Guest]

Cheers for that , i did`t mean to question why the topic was closed just the way to do it, for future reference.

Liar.. don't be afraid to be belligerent LOL

[Winnie :-)]

No, really, I do say it how it is.. that's why everyone hates me LOL.. Cast your mind back... remember the Nauseating Bimbo who shouldn't ever grace the soul scene? That's me

Hehehe

Who gives a twopenny bit? We're still here Winnie, bolstering what we believe in.. that's cool.

===========

I'm aware you tell it like it is, but I'm unaware of the Nauseating Bimbo reference. Did I miss something on SS? Can't remember anybody hating you either, but then I love everyone

Winnie:-)

[Guest garv]

Liar.. don't be afraid to be belligerent LOL

Dont call me a liar........................ok................................. hows that for being belligerent , my question related to the working`s of the closing down of a topic............

[Winnie :-)]

I could just snog you LOL... please don't derogitarily reply, let me hold that thought

Seriously, as Mike say's, passion comes from many an angle, something you cannot quantify nor qualify.. it's personal and it .... you know what I mean

===============

Seriously I agree with you, some records just do it for you, and a lot of the time it's almost impossible to say why. Whatever does the trick, then that's your pick!

Winnie:-)

[Guest]

It was about 6 years ago... yes, women do have good memories! There was a post about me. It read.

You're a naueseating bimbo, the soul scene would be a better place without you

OK, I'm not over it, but I'm working on it Weird how things stick.

It was probably MIke hahahahaaa

[Winnie :-)]

It was about 6 years ago... yes, women do have good memories! There was a post about me. It read.

You're a naueseating bimbo, the soul scene would be a better place without you

OK, I'm not over it, but I'm working on it Weird how things stick.

It was probably MIke hahahahaaa

===========

I wasn't on here then, but I would have defended your absolute right to be as nauseating and as bimboesque as you wanted to be.

I admire someone who speaks their mind, so fair play to you!

Winnie

[Guest]

No, really, I am a nauesating bimbo That's what hurt the most

[Mike]

============

I know why Pete posts the sort of thing he does.....because the scene does come across as snobbish at times, particularly from within. Some of the records mentioned in his thread have nothing to do with northern, but over the years have been force fed to the N/S community IMO because of their rarity. I don't agree with him about all his choices, but surely most can see where he' s coming from.

I asked in a recent thread why, when inducting new people into the soul scene we invariably play them something up tempo, and considered an oldie. Never got a reply (as far as I can remember) but would you really play someone new "The feeling is real" to explain northern? I think the only thing Pete ever does is stand his corner, and promote his choice/style of northern, and personally I don't see anything wrong with that.

Winnie:-)

winnie

see I would challenge your views "....have nothing to do with northern" and "force fed"

fair enough if had said your idea of northern , but given fact that so far imo no one has ever been able to come out with a definte "what is northen" find that such a general view dont really hold up

surely due to the wide range of styles been played since early days the only qualification that a record needs to be considered northern is that it was/is played at a northern soul event

yeah sure maybe wouldn't play someone new "the feeling is real" but then wouldnt play them "long after tonight etc" either

Myself reckon one of the postive things about northern nowadays is the range of styles of soul it covers, to try and narrow that range down to a certain style of uptempo 60s dance records can't be a good thing can it ?

as for "force fed" .. another day maybe

Edited November 9, 2005 by mike-

[Winnie :-)]

winnie

see I would challenge your views "....have nothing to do with northern" and "force fed"

fair enough if had said your idea of northern , but given fact that so far imo no one has ever been able to come out with a definte "what is northen" find that such a general view dont really hold up

surely due to the wide range of styles been played since early days the only qualification that a record needs to be considered northern is that it was/is played at a northern soul event

yeah sure maybe wouldn't play someone new "the feeling is real" but then wouldnt play them "long after tonight etc" either

Myself reckon one of the postive things about northern nowadays is the range of styles of soul it covers, to try and narrow that range down to a certain style of uptempo 60s dance records can't be a good thing can it ?

as for "force fed" .. another day maybe

================

I should have said traditional Northern Soul. Most have an idea of what it sounds like, for instance the mello souls would fit nicely into any era, and I would guess be accepted by all. Dotty and Milly on the other hand (personal dislike) in my view doesn't. I'm not opposed to new sounds being played, or great old ones being re-activated, and IMO the Dome did a really good job at that. But I do feel we are force fed sub-standard records just because of their rarity. At times to me it seems like the rarity has become more important than the quality. I know it's not a popular view amongst many active SS'rs but it's how I feel

I do prefer my soul up-tempo, but do like things across the board, I just can't buy into the newies are best carte blanche. As Soul girl said, it's what moves you, and I know where my heart lies Although I do like quite a bit of modern

Winnie:-)

[Guest Baz]

============

but would you really play someone new "The feeling is real" to explain northern?

Winnie:-)

Why not, sums it up in the title very nicely ..........The feeling is real

[sister dawn]

================

I should have said traditional Northern Soul. Most have an idea of what it sounds like, for instance the mello souls would fit nicely into any era, and I would guess be accepted by all. Dotty and Milly on the other hand (personal dislike) in my view doesn't. I'm not opposed to new sounds being played, or great old ones being re-activated, and IMO the Dome did a really good job at that. But I do feel we are force fed sub-standard records just because of their rarity. At times to me it seems like the rarity has become more important than the quality. I know it's not a popular view amongst many active SS'rs but it's how I feel

I do prefer my soul up-tempo, but do like things across the board, I just can't buy into the newies are best carte blanche. As Soul girl said, it's what moves you, and I know where my heart lies Although I do like quite a bit of modern

Winnie:-)

It always has been present on the scene Winnie since I first got into the northern scene in the mid 7ts, (the rarities) I think that some (and only some) of the dj's on the scene get a bit too wrapped up in the label side of it. One experience that i had re this was when a couple of major collectors spun "pounds" on the turntable one night where they were guesting, the venue was full but the dance floor empty, individuals were going up to make requests that were never played and the dj's sneered at them as if to say "we aint gonna play that shite" and just carried on spinning the rarest of the rare to an empty floor... the venue suffered badly after that... personally I am a retro girl and like my northern that way, what peeves me though is a venue that advertises northern and plays arm swinging modern and related commercial motown... and woe betide you if you ask for any northern to be played ...

[Winnie :-)]

It always has been present on the scene Winnie since I first got into the northern scene in the mid 7ts, (the rarities) I think that some (and only some) of the dj's on the scene get a bit too wrapped up in the label side of it. One experience that i had re this was when a couple of major collectors spun "pounds" on the turntable one night where they were guesting, the venue was full but the dance floor empty, individuals were going up to make requests that were never played and the dj's sneered at them as if to say "we aint gonna play that shite" and just carried on spinning the rarest of the rare to an empty floor... the venue suffered badly after that... personally I am a retro girl and like my northern that way, what peeves me though is a venue that advertises northern and plays arm swinging modern and related commercial motown... and woe betide you if you ask for any northern to be played ...

===========

Yes there were rarities in the 70Ts, but essentially they were also records that stood up on their own merits. Course there were a lot more records to discover at that time, which would logically mean the quality wouldn't have to drop. Nowadays.....well, maybe that's not the case. Just a thought

Winnie;-)

[Guest Dan]

I asked in a recent thread why, when inducting new people into the soul scene we invariably play them something up tempo, and considered an oldie. Never got a reply (as far as I can remember) but would you really play someone new "The feeling is real" to explain northern?

Winnie:-)

come a bit late to this thread

agree with most of what you say winnie but think i would play 'the feeling is real' to newcomers, yes.

i recently answered a 'what record sums up northern for you' thread with 'i'm coming home' but this is a very theoretical 'if i ruled the world' type question and if i really HAD to come up with just one record to sum up northern i couldn't do it.

never mind one record to sum up northern, i couldn't even come up with one record to sum up my own experience of northern, or my memories of the scene.

equally, if asked to introduce someone new to northern (which i'm always trying to do anyway as probably most of us are in our own way) i wouldn't play just ONE record, be it george pepp or any other.

what i generally do is knock together a cd with about 30 tracks on it for anyone who shows any real interest - i don't actually like george pepp but it could well be one of those 30 tracks because it helps to sum up northern (as would, say, pyramid, or i've had it, or i just kept on dancing [and cajun hart, lou pride, most of the magnetics, gwen owens etc etc])

you can't sum up northern soul with just one record in any meaningful way - an uptempo stomper with xylophones, strings and brass and lots of backdrop breaks would sum up part of it, but not all of it.

[Winnie :-)]

come a bit late to this thread

agree with most of what you say winnie but think i would play 'the feeling is real' to newcomers, yes.

i recently answered a 'what record sums up northern for you' thread with 'i'm coming home' but this is a very theoretical 'if i ruled the world' type question and if i really HAD to come up with just one record to sum up northern i couldn't do it.

never mind one record to sum up northern, i couldn't even come up with one record to sum up my own experience of northern, or my memories of the scene.

equally, if asked to introduce someone new to northern (which i'm always trying to do anyway as probably most of us are in our own way) i wouldn't play just ONE record, be it george pepp or any other.

what i generally do is knock together a cd with about 30 tracks on it for anyone who shows any real interest - i don't actually like george pepp but it could well be one of those 30 tracks because it helps to sum up northern (as would, say, pyramid, or i've had it, or i just kept on dancing [and cajun hart, lou pride, most of the magnetics, gwen owens etc etc])

you can't sum up northern soul with just one record in any meaningful way - an uptempo stomper with xylophones, strings and brass and lots of backdrop breaks would sum up part of it, but not all of it.

============

The thread I was referring to was a couple of weeks ago I think. And it asked what one record would you play to someone just coming into the N/S scene to explain it. Personally I agree with you, no one record can describe N/S adequately, because it has so many flavours. But people did try to answer it, and the one very noticable thing was that the vast majority of answers were what would be considered, played out oldies. I found it interesting considering the amount of oldies/newies/rare/not so rare debates on here. What it seemed to say to me was, that the older records were what N/S was really about. Granted there has to be new additions to playlists to keep the scene fresh, but the only one that got a mention (as I can remember) in the playing it to a newcomer was mello souls. Personally I think Mello souls would have graced any era and is a traditional sounding northern record, so no great change from playing a newcomer an oldie

Winnie;-)

[Mike]

It always has been present on the scene Winnie since I first got into the northern scene in the mid 7ts, (the rarities) I think that some (and only some) of the dj's on the scene get a bit too wrapped up in the label side of it. One experience that i had re this was when a couple of major collectors spun "pounds" on the turntable one night where they were guesting, the venue was full but the dance floor empty, individuals were going up to make requests that were never played and the dj's sneered at them as if to say "we aint gonna play that shite" and just carried on spinning the rarest of the rare to an empty floor... the venue suffered badly after that... personally I am a retro girl and like my northern that way, what peeves me though is a venue that advertises northern and plays arm swinging modern and related commercial motown... and woe betide you if you ask for any northern to be played ...

Interesting that Dan used "I'm coming home" as a example of what northern is about , which many may nod and agree with, and sure is a popular sound at retro events, yet the intial reaction to that when first played as a new sound was empty floors

What would have happened if dj then had sacked it and took the easy way out ?

[sister dawn]

Interesting that Dan used "I'm coming home" as a example of what northern is about , which many may nod and agree with, and sure is a popular sound at retro events, yet the intial reaction to that when first played as a new sound was empty floors

What would have happened if dj then had sacked it and took the easy way out ?

I know what you are saying Mike, but I think the way that I read winnies post and replied was that sometimes the odd few forget about the dance floor and have little competitions between themselves when behind the decks with the rarest of the rare stuff, dont get me wrong sounds have to break somewhere and somehow, but are done in such a way, as I am sure you know, not to cause over kill in its initial first few plays. But if you want it to "sound a bit different" or "stand out" from the others then dont play the stuff all night long.

Well known for beyond its time sounds, as you know was the pier at Cleethorpes they had a great reputation for breaking new stuff on the scene at the time but they also played the good old tried and previously tested sounds.