Trading records/cash with a friend for a copy of this and am wondering what SoulSourcers would rate it at pricewise, popsike of course says $1500 for a VG+ last year so it looks as if i'm going to hav e to dig deep, but thought i would see what folks on here thought. Thanks in advance

In my opinion no more than £400 - £500 tops. Great record BTW.

Russ

A VG+ one went on Ebay a couple of months ago for something around £900, which did seem a lot to me.

But then again, it is a truly awesome tune and I am very jealous

I would agree with Russ in the real world. £900 does seem a lot. It's tough but not like there hasn't been any copies on the market.

  On 08/07/2011 at 08:02, chalky said:

I would agree with Russ in the real world. £900 does seem a lot. It's tough but not like there hasn't been any copies on the market.

Oh I know, £900 is a lot. I was just telling him what it went for that's all.

If anybody has one of these in E+ to M- condition for £400 t0 £500 I'll take it now!!!!!!!!!!

Ricardo.

  On 08/07/2011 at 08:08, jumpinjoan said:

Oh I know, £900 is a lot. I was just telling him what it went for that's all.

I was agreeing with you Joan

  On 08/07/2011 at 10:10, chalky said:

I was agreeing with you Joan.

Ooops

Thanks very much everyone, fortunately for myself dealer is a nice guy and would rather see it go to a friend than onto ebay which seems a rarer beast every day, unfortunately I blew most of my trade on the last "biggish" tune so it's one meal a day this month i think really appreciate the input

  On 08/07/2011 at 03:49, Russ Vickers said:

In my opinion no more than £400 - £500 tops. Great record BTW.

Russ

From the perspective of someone who does'nt have one ..but would like one

Last decent one was on Manship auction a few months back for just over £1400

  On 08/07/2011 at 12:04, NEV said:

From the perspective of someone who does'nt have one ..but would like one

Last decent one was on Manship auction a few months back for just over £1400

Russ

  On 08/07/2011 at 12:14, Russ Vickers said:

Russ

WHAT ARE YOU LAUGHING FOR.... LOTS OF NOT SO RARE RECORDS GO FOR OVER A GRAND. MAYBE JM`S COPY OF £1400 IS O.T.T BUT IF YOU THINK THIS RECORD IS ONLY £4/500 LETS JUST SAY YOU ARE OUT OF TOUCH

DAVE

  On 08/07/2011 at 16:57, dave pinch said:

WHAT ARE YOU LAUGHING FOR.... LOTS OF NOT SO RARE RECORDS GO FOR OVER A GRAND. MAYBE JM`S COPY OF £1400 IS O.T.T BUT IF YOU THINK THIS RECORD IS ONLY £4/500 LETS JUST SAY YOU ARE OUT OF TOUCH

DAVE

I must be out of touch Dave, can't find it right now but sure I put one on Andy D's list year ago? Seen it in at least two sales boxes for around that and not sure if been on SS for around that. Stick em in a sales box and you can't shift them put them in an auction and they fetch more than they should in the real world

  On 08/07/2011 at 17:02, chalky said:

I must be out of touch Dave, can't find it right now but sure I put one on Andy D's list year ago? Seen it in at least two sales boxes for around that and not sure if been on SS for around that. Stick em in a sales box and you can't shift them put them in an auction and they fetch more than they should in the real world

THATS TRUE....LOOK AT RECENT PRICES FOR INSPIRATIONS AND IVORIES.... MADNESS FOR TWO RECORDS THAT ARE COMMON MORE THAN RARE.... BUT MILTON PARKER WAS 4/500 10 YEARS AGO... IF SOMEONE HAS IT IN THEIR BOX AT THAT PRICE AND DOESNT SELL IT THER`E VISITING THE WRONG VENUES. WORTH DOUBLE THAT IMO FOR A CLEAN COPY

DAVE

  On 08/07/2011 at 16:57, dave pinch said:

WHAT ARE YOU LAUGHING FOR.... LOTS OF NOT SO RARE RECORDS GO FOR OVER A GRAND. MAYBE JM`S COPY OF £1400 IS O.T.T BUT IF YOU THINK THIS RECORD IS ONLY £4/500 LETS JUST SAY YOU ARE OUT OF TOUCH

DAVE

I'm laughing because its not worth that, great record, even owned it once upon a time, I dont mind what people pay Dave, but what people will pay on ebay & JM Auction are not generally realistic prices that the same items would fetch in a box at a Nighter.

Not selling one are you .

Russ

Edited July 8, 201113 yr by Russ Vickers

  On 08/07/2011 at 17:36, Russ Vickers said:

I'm laughing because its not worth that, great record, even owned it once upon a time, I dont mind what people pay Dave, but what people will pay on ebay & JM Auction are not generally realistic prices that the same items would fetch in a box at a Nighter.

Not selling one are you .

Russ

For some reason i alwasy wanted a copy of Matt Brown and to me i kinda thought there was a similarity between the two ...but Matt just neevr quite cut it for me ..this on the other hand kills me everytime

  On 08/07/2011 at 16:57, dave pinch said:

WHAT ARE YOU LAUGHING FOR.... LOTS OF NOT SO RARE RECORDS GO FOR OVER A GRAND. MAYBE JM`S COPY OF £1400 IS O.T.T BUT IF YOU THINK THIS RECORD IS ONLY £4/500 LETS JUST SAY YOU ARE OUT OF TOUCH

DAVE

STOP SHOUTING DAVE

Not selling one are you .

Russ

PUT IT THIS WAY RUSS, I'D RUB THE RECORD QUITE HARSHLY UP AGAINST THE WOODCHIP WALLPAPER ON MI BEDROOM WALL, GRIND MI TEETH ON IT AND THEN DO A CUPPLE O' SPINS ON IT AS WELL,THEN YES IT'S YOURS FOR 400 QUID

BRI PINCH (P S NEV WILL SELL HIS VERY SHORTLY, COS HE HAD IT LONGER THAN TWO WEEKS )

  On 08/07/2011 at 18:10, bri pinch said:

Not selling one are you .

Russ

PUT IT THIS WAY RUSS, I'D RUB THE RECORD QUITE HARSHLY UP AGAINST THE WOODCHIP WALLPAPER ON MI BEDROOM WALL, GRIND MI TEETH ON IT AND THEN DO A CUPPLE O' SPINS ON IT AS WELL,THEN YES IT'S YOURS FOR 400 QUID

BRI PINCH (P S NEV WILL SELL HIS VERY SHORTLY, COS HE HAD IT LONGER THAN TWO WEEKS )

You shouldnt go to all that trouble just for me Bri.......I'm only expressing an opinion & of course I may be wrong, but I stand by my opinion that it isnt worth what JM got for it & what the copy on ebay went for......

And tell Dave to stop shouting at me .

Russ

Edited July 8, 201113 yr by Russ Vickers

NO, YOU'RE NOT WRONG RUSS, PRICE IS A BIT INFLATED ON THIS AT THE MO, AND OUR DAVE SHOUTING IS MY FAULT AS I'VE ALWAYS GOT THE KEYS ON CAPS LOCKED

REGARDS, BRI

sorry guys dint mean to shout. av got dun na

dave

Its a grand all day long, loads of people after it....and it packs the floor everytime at every venue...well everywhere I go to anyway!

Chris

  On 08/07/2011 at 18:10, bri pinch said:

Not selling one are you .

Russ

PUT IT THIS WAY RUSS, I'D RUB THE RECORD QUITE HARSHLY UP AGAINST THE WOODCHIP WALLPAPER ON MI BEDROOM WALL, GRIND MI TEETH ON IT AND THEN DO A CUPPLE O' SPINS ON IT AS WELL,THEN YES IT'S YOURS FOR 400 QUID

BRI PINCH (P S NEV WILL SELL HIS VERY SHORTLY, COS HE HAD IT LONGER THAN TWO WEEKS )

Bri ...you bitch...i preferred you shouting

I thought being progressive meant just that ...keep moving and stop hanging onto oldies

  On 09/07/2011 at 14:10, NEV said:

Bri ...you bitch...i preferred you shouting

I thought being progressive meant just that ...keep moving and stop hanging onto oldies

First dib's NevI'm wounded by the Matt Brown comment, having recently bought one

  On 09/07/2011 at 14:23, Tony Jackson said:

First dib's NevI'm wounded by the Matt Brown comment, having recently bought one

Matt Brown - Sweet Thing/Thank You Baby? Milton Parker good record but Matt Brown p*sses all over it

  On 09/07/2011 at 14:45, chalky said:

Matt Brown - Sweet Thing/Thank You Baby? Milton Parker good record but Matt Brown p*sses all over it

Well that confirms it Chalky ...you don't have any taste in soul music

Shame cos your a nice bloke and i had high hopes for you

  On 09/07/2011 at 15:45, NEV said:

Well that confirms it Chalky ...you don't have any taste in soul music

Shame cos your a nice bloke and i had high hopes for you

I've been converted to the Javells Nev

  On 09/07/2011 at 16:27, chalky said:

I've been converted to the Javells Nev

  On 09/07/2011 at 16:27, chalky said:

I've been converted to the Javells Nev

Well I'm staying in the CLOSET

me too.matt brown good......but milton better imho............... whats matt fetchin 4 ish?

dave

  On 09/07/2011 at 19:31, dave pinch said:

me too.matt brown good......but milton better imho............... whats matt fetchin 4 ish?

dave

The only time i had Matt Brown i got the full book price of £600 for it Dave , however it was Mint- , and was a couple of years ago now , ( when selling records for top dollar was somewhat easier than it is now ) , i doubt i could get that for it again ?

I'm afraid i'm like Chalky and have no taste either , as Milton P. is a non-starter against Matt B. in my book , but everyone has their own "take" on comparisons . O.k. tune but not for me , could just simply be that the Jar-val labels far prettier to me ?

  On 09/07/2011 at 20:08, bitchdj said:

The only time i had Matt Brown i got the full book price of £600 for it Dave , however it was Mint- , and was a couple of years ago now , ( when selling records for top dollar was somewhat easier than it is now ) , i doubt i could get that for it again ?

I'm afraid i'm like Chalky and have no taste either , as Milton P. is a non-starter against Matt B. in my book , but everyone has their own "take" on comparisons . O.k. tune but not for me , could just simply be that the Jar-val labels far prettier to me ?

i never owned it kim although i do love it........... couldnt afford £600. unless i sold more stuff

dave

In my experience (only) the Milton Parker is a very hard record indeed,if i remember around the time of the canal tavern a few surfaced-since then very few .I'd want a grand if i found a spare....

maybe if i convert myself to ove to the Javells i can save a bit of money then?

luckily i have the javells.do you think i could sell it and put the proceeds to a matt brown

dave

  On 09/07/2011 at 20:08, bitchdj said:

The only time i had Matt Brown i got the full book price of £600 for it Dave , however it was Mint- , and was a couple of years ago now , ( when selling records for top dollar was somewhat easier than it is now ) , i doubt i could get that for it again ?

I'm afraid i'm like Chalky and have no taste either , as Milton P. is a non-starter against Matt B. in my book , but everyone has their own "take" on comparisons . O.k. tune but not for me , could just simply be that the Jar-val labels far prettier to me ?

hi Cookie

It's great that we all have our personal opinion and everyone is entitled .

For what its worth imho ,they are both great records and both double sided,infact they shouldn't even be compared.

I brought it into the topic because whenever i hear Matt Brown it always reminds me of Milton Parker,its probably only the backing at the beginning of the record?

Price wise..I think a few Matt browns have turned up over the last 5yrs against very few M.P's .

I do recall my good friend Shep trying to sell a M Brown on here a bit back and struggled to get £300 for it ?

Slightly on a tangent here but i seem to recall that it was the flip of Matt Brown getting noticed ,that created a rise in demand in recent yrs?

Never my favourite side but again that's just a personal opinion.

Best

Nev

  On 09/07/2011 at 21:32, Dysonsoul said:

In my experience (only) the Milton Parker is a very hard record indeed,if i remember around the time of the canal tavern a few surfaced-since then very few .I'd want a grand if i found a spare....

Hi Andy

Was or is there any other Closet 45's ?

Without digging out my copy....seem to recall it was Milton Parker's own label?

  On 10/07/2011 at 10:05, NEV said:

Slightly on a tangent here but i seem to recall that it was the flip of Matt Brown getting noticed ,that created a rise in demand in recent yrs?

Never my favourite side but again that's just a personal opinion.

Best

Nev

Both sides of Matt Brown been played since the Stafford days.

I agree with you though you can't really compare the two records, both good 45's in their own right.

I surrender.........

Russ

  On 10/07/2011 at 10:09, NEV said:

Hi Andy

Was or is there any other Closet 45's ?

Without digging out my copy....seem to recall it was Milton Parker's own label?

I assume it was his label,he produced and penned the 2 sides,In the late 80's on a buying trip i found another record by him on the same label,but it was spoken word one side and a kinda political promotion song on the flip... i may even have it still in me mothers loft.. it wasn't in any shape or form anything to do with soul.

  On 10/07/2011 at 11:36, Dysonsoul said:

I assume it was his label,he produced and penned the 2 sides,In the late 80's on a buying trip i found another record by him on the same label,but it was spoken word one side and a kinda political promotion song on the flip... i may even have it still in me mothers loft.. it wasn't in any shape or form anything to do with soul.

If it's not soul then why don't you put it into your Dj spot Mr. D , with the rest of 'em ?

awsome tune and imho easily worth a grand cos its a hard one to find but if i was buying no more than £600 for a minter no im not after a copy unless its on the never never

  On 09/07/2011 at 14:10, NEV said:

Bri ...you bitch...i preferred you shouting

I thought being progressive meant just that ...keep moving and stop hanging onto oldies

mmmm any closer to parting with you know what Nev

  On 10/07/2011 at 11:46, bitchdj said:

If it's not soul then why don't you put it into your Dj spot Mr. D , with the rest of 'em ?

Ah because dear Nick that particular box (s) are full apart from the many i've sold you !

  On 10/07/2011 at 11:48, Bearsy said:

mmmm any closer to parting with you know what Nev

you just said you were skint???

And according to a recent thread ,it's worth a lot more than i thought

  On 10/07/2011 at 11:49, Dysonsoul said:

Ah because dear Nick that particular box (s) are full apart from the many i've sold you !

Touche !

Sad but true. You may go back up t'loft now.

  On 10/07/2011 at 11:53, NEV said:

you just said you were skint???

And according to a recent thread ,it's worth a lot more than i thought

for everything else in life im skint but i have a reserve put aside just for this and its over rated and not worth much really but i still want it

remember my mate telling me that he picked up 5 copies in the states,from one of his record hunting trips.late 80's early 90's.

kept one & sold the rest @ £75 a pop.not sure if he still has it tho.

he was on the modern scene @ the time.

said £75 was alot then to pay for a modern tune,as most the tunes were £10/15.

big devide then between modern/northern.northern scene didnt want the modern tunes.

they do now